William Cavanaugh

Interview: William Cavanaugh, After Atheism, Part Three

Letters:

Aug 28, 2018, from David: I learned yesterday from Sajay Samuel that you have commented on the book of Illich's early writings that the Penn State Press will be publishing in December.  Thank you.  Sajay, whom I've copied, intends to launch the book will a small gathering in State College at the very end of November (Nov. 30-Dec. 2), and we're both wondering if you'd be able to join us.  Not a full-blown conference by any means...something smaller and more leisurely with lots of time for food, drink and fellowship, in the style of the man we're remembering.  Sajay and I and another friend, Carl Mitcham, will speak, as will Wolfgang Palaver from Innsbruck who's in Princeton this fall (and someone, I suspect, you might know.)  We'd love to have you there to share your thoughts as well.  There is money for your travel and accomodation, and it's not that far from Chicago to State College.  Any chance you could come?

Aug 29, 2018, from Bill: It's great to hear from you.  Thanks very much for the invitation.  I hate to say "no" again, but I'm at Notre Dame on a fellowship.  One of the conditions of the fellowship is that we are in residence here for the duration.  Given that this is my first sabbatical since 2001, and it's only a semester, I have turned down every invitation for the fall.  Please accept my regrets.  It sounds like a great program, and it would be great to meet you in person and see Wolfgang again.  But for now I will have to decline.

Aug 30, 2018, from David:  I understand, of course, but I'm sorry just the same.  I hope there'll be another chance down the road.  Meanwhile thanks for supporting The Powerless Church.  I'll be in touch again when my book on Illich is done - I hope to have it in the hands of the Penn State Press by later in the fall. 

——

Sep 12, 2019, from Bill: I'm writing to ask if you might entertain an invitation to come speak on Ivan Illich at DePaul in Chicago next April.  I am now director of a research center on the Catholic Church in the global South, and our big annual conference next year is going to be on healthcare and the Church in the global South.  We will have people from around the world talking about what works and what doesn't in Catholic healthcare, the theological foundations for thinking about these issues, North-South cooperation, the collision between Western and non-Western medicine, etc.  I thought that you might be the ideal person to shake things up a bit and offer Illich's take on the practice of medicine, relating it, insofar as it's possible, to his Catholicism and his work in Latin America.

I'd like you to be one of the keynote speakers at the conference, which will take place over the weekend of April 17-19, 2020.  We can cover all your expenses plus a modest $1500 honorarium.  I'll send you a more formal invitation if you are open to it.  But first I wanted to gauge your interest.  

I'd love to finally meet you in person.

Sep 13, 2019, from David:  Off the top of my head this sounds like something I would like to do.  My book should be in press by then, and I had anticipated that, as of next year, I would have to start standing up for it, so your invitation exactly fits.  Plus it would be a chance to meet you - at last.  So, tentatively, yes...

         A veil of discretion is supposed to lie over the identity of the readers of my Illich MS, but it was not difficult to descry your features in what came to me as the comments of "reader two."  Thank you for your generous endorsement, as well as for your more critical comments.  The reader reports - yours along with that of the equally enthusiastic, and helpfully critical "reader one" (Wolfgang Palaver) - have given the Penn State Press the confidence to proceed and to seek a co-publication arrangement with the McGll/Queens Press here in Canada.  They have also given me a set of pointed questions with which to undertake a final - I hope - revision which I expect to  complete within the month. 

Sep 13, 2019, from Bill: That's great news, David!  My assistant will send you a formal letter of invitation. 

Now that I have been outed as "reader two," let me tell you how excited I was to read your book and how happy that it will soon be available to the public.  It's terrific, and I learned so much from it.

— — 

September 16, 2019, from Karen Kraft: Dear Mr. Cayley:

In April of 2020, the Center for World Catholicism & Intercultural Theology (CWCIT) of DePaul University in Chicago will host its 12th annual World Catholicism Week conference. Titled “Rise Up and Walk: Catholicism and Health Across the Globe,” the conference will take place here at DePaul over the weekend of April 17-19, 2020 (Friday afternoon through Sunday evening). I would like to invite you to join us as one of our two keynote speakers, giving a 45-minute presentation on the conference theme. I know you receive many invitations, but I am hoping that the global focus of the conference and DePaul’s Vincentian tradition will be added incentives for you to accept.

The CWCIT (http://cwcit.depaul.edu) is a research center at DePaul that focuses on the global dimensions of Catholicism, particularly in the global South—Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Each year, World Catholicism Week gathers scholars and practitioners from around the world to reflect on a theme. The theme for 2020 is Catholicism and health care around the world. Topics may include Catholic health care services, biblical and theological narratives of health and healing, Catholicism and the relationship between Western and non-Western medicine, trauma and invisible wounds, Catholic health care ethics, caring for those wounded by the Church, and others. As keynote speaker, you would be free to draw on your extensive expertise in Catholic health care to address the topic from any angle you would see fit. Some connection with health care issues in the global South would be especially appreciated.

Our other invited speakers include the following: Sr. Carol Keehan, DC–Outgoing President/CEO, Catholic Health Association (Washington, DC); David Toole—Associate Professor of the Practice of Theology, Ethics, and Global Health, Duke Global Health Institute (Durham, NC, USA); Sr. Dr. Maria Vasantha—Medical Superintendent, Leonard Hospital (Batlagundu, Tamil Nadu, India); Alexandre Martins—Assistant Professor of Theology, Marquette University (Milwaukee, WI, USA); Fr. Stan Chu Ilo—Associate Professor of Theology & CWCIT Research Professor, DePaul University (Chicago);  Fr. Paulino Twesigye Mondo, MCCI—Immediate Past Director, Reach Out Mbuya HIV Initiative (Kampala); Kochurani Abraham—Regional Coordinator, Indian Christian Women’s Movement for Kerala; Vice President, Indian Theological Association (Bengaluru, Kamataka, India); Fr. Bernhard Udelhoven, SMA—Founder, “Fingers of Thomas” support group, and staff member of FENZA—Faith & Encounter Centre Zambia (Lusaka); Sr. Joan Mumaw, IHM—President & Chief Administrative Officer, Friends in Soliarity (Silver Spring, MD, USA); David Gaus, MD—Founder & CEO, Andean Health & Development (Rural Ecuador); Sam Orach—Executive Secretary, Uganda Catholic Medical Bureau; Member, Health Policy Advisory; Committee, Uganda Ministry of Health (Kampala, Uganda).

 In general, the time allotted for keynote presentations is 45 minutes, plus an additional 20-30 for audience Q&A.

——

Jan 4, 2021, from Karen: Dear friends, Hello from DePaul during these first few days of 2021! I hope that all of you are keeping well and have had a peaceful Christmas. 

I’m writing with some very important requests and updates for our “Rise Up and Walk” conference on Zoom this April. As you know, there is always the possibility of unforeseen technical difficulties during an online event, and we want to be as prepared as possible. To that end, we would like to ask each of you to please record a video of yourself giving your conference presentation, well in advance.  

Could we ask you to send us your video file—along with the text of your final presentation—by Friday, March 19? 

We understand that, for some of you, this might be an incredibly ambitious request, but we hope that we are asking far enough in advance that you have time to prepare. These videos will serve as “insurance,” in case something goes wrong with your internet connection on the day of your conference presentation. If that happens, and you aren’t able to get online, we will be able to show your video and not lose the contribution and insight you bring to this important conference.

 Jan 4, 2021, from David:  Thanks for your recent letter.  There have been some changes in my life, since I agreed […] that I would make my address to the conference as planned, but not otherwise participate.  Towards the end of November, I began to develop serious angina, and an angiogram has since revealed fairly extensive blockages in my coronary arteries.  The upshot is that I will have open heart surgery and multiple bypasses on Jan. 15th.  How this will go is uncertain.  With a good recovery I should be able to make your March 19th deadline, but I wanted to let you both know that that might be in doubt if there are any complications.  I will write again in  February when I know my situation better.  I hope this is acceptable.  If you want to cancel me and substitute someone you can count on with more confidence, I will understand.  If not, I'll write when I can.

 Jan.8, 2021, from Karen: Thank you for writing […] and please forgive this delayed reply…I am so sorry to learn of the angina that has developed since we were last in touch and the resulting need for you to undergo open-heart surgery next week. Please rest assured of our prayers…that both the surgery and the recovery are successful and sans complications. Regarding the conference, we all agree that we would hate to lose your contribution as a keynoter. We’re glad to wait to hear from you in February, when you have a little recovery time under your belt and can better assess how you are doing. […] Count on our prayers for next Friday, David…and please take good care in the coming weeks. God bless….

Jan 9, 2021, from Bill: I just wanted to add my concern to that of Karen.  I'm sorry to hear of your medical issues, and I will be praying that all goes well for you.  Please let us know, when you can, how the surgery went, and let us know if there is anything you need from us.

Jan 11, 2021, from David: Thanks for your letters.  Since I wrote, I have decided to postpone the surgery because of the uncertain effect of rising COVID numbers on the hospital (and me as its patient), and because current restrictions on visitors would make me a virtual captive, cut off from all my loved ones, should something go wrong.  Happily I feel quite well and able to sustain the delay.   The surgery is not yet rescheduled, but 'll certainly be able to deliver my recorded lecture before March 19th.  So count on that, and I'll be in touch later on.

 Jan 11, 2021, from Bill: Thanks, David.  I'm glad to hear that you're feeling well and can wait until the pandemic gets a little more under control.  We're very much looking forward to your talk.  I can imagine that you might have a thing or two to say about the pandemic.

——

Jan 26, 2026, from David:  Greetings from snowbound Toronto - where a couple of feet of snow fell on the city yesterday.

          Quite a few years ago I invited you to an Illich gathering - I think it was in Oakland when Jerry Brown was the mayor there - and you said you would have liked to come even though you couldn't.  Here I am trying again.  My friend Sajay Samuel, a professor at Penn State, is inviting contributions to a volume called The Challenges of Ivan Illich - a sequel to a book of that name which appeared just before Ivan died.  I've attached his call for papers.  He intends to host a gathering in State College, PA in the first week of August this coming summer where some of those contributions will be discussed.  I wonder if there's any chance you could come.

       I've also attached an essay I've just provisionally completed, which tries to read C.G. Jung with and against Illich, and for which I'm not seeking interlocutors, since it's written, pretty much, from the frontier of my understanding.  It's long, and I have no wish to impose it on you, but I don't want to completely hide my light under a bushel either, so I leave it to you to decide if it's of interest. 

      I've just begun reading your Uses of Idolatry.  I send you my best wishes.

2 Attachments  •  (Jung essay and Challenges 2 conference outline)

 Jan 27, 2026, from Bill: It's great to hear from you. I still regret not being able to attend that gathering in Oakland. Unfortunately, I can't be at the State College gathering either. I'll be doing a series of talks in Switzerland the first week of August. 

 I'm really sorry about this. I plan to finally do a serious dive into Illich for my next book, which is probably ten years from appearing in print. In the meantime, I will read your essay on Illich and Jung with rapt attention.

Jan 28, 2026, from David:  Thanks for yours.  I'm sorry to hear about this summer, and Sajay's book, but delighted that Illich is on your horizon - however far it may stretch.  

          If you do read the essay I sent you, I hope you will read it charitably as the work of a theological ingénue who is trying to get certain questions clearer in his mind rather than as some sort of statement of position - I'm a long way from that. 

Lee Hoinacki

Lee speaking on the programs: Part Moon, Part Travelling Salesman: Conversations with Ivan Illich, Parts 1 & 5

From Jutta: Lee Hoinacki was Ivan Illich’s friend and collaborator. Whenever David visited Ivan, Lee would most likely be there. David loved Lee, and so did lots of other people. In 2014, David came across an interview that Richard Whittaker did with Lee in 2004, linked on John Verity’s blog New Scare City. He sent it to me, and after David died, I found it again.

It’s a really interesting interview, and I emailed the website “Works and Conversations” to find out if they would allow me to reprint it. But there was no response. I worry, though, that if the organization ever winds up its affairs, the interview will be lost. So I’m reprinting it without permission, hoping that at some point I can contact them.

David kept this photo of Lee, beside the photo of Illich’s grave, on the bookshelf near his writing desk, and often looked at it.

Conversation with Lee Hoinacki: Conscience and Courage

by Richard Whittaker, Sep 21, 2004

photo - r. whittaker

(Reprinted from the Journal Works and Conversations https://www.conversations.org/story.php?sid=5. )


One day, browsing through the San Francisco Chronicle, I noticed the announcement of a program being put on by Oakland Mayor Jerry Brown. Among the list of topics were two evenings devoted to medieval philosophical Latin. Medieval philosophical Latin? Sure enough, that’s what it said. I'd taken Latin in high school and on no account would I miss a civic program so improbable. It marked my introduction to a remarkable man, Lee Hoinacki.

Hoinacki by turns had been a Dominican priest, a professor of political science and a subsistence farmer. He's the author of four books: El Camino, Stumbling Toward Justice, Dying Is Not Death and The Challenge of Ivan Illich. For decades, Hoinacki and Ivan Illich were the closest of friends.

In his Latin presentation that first evening, he made it a point to discount his own expertise. In truth though, Hoinacki was a scholar. He told us that reading St. Thomas Aquinas in Latin is much clearer than reading him in English. And while he downplayed his accomplishments, it was soon clear that I was listening to a man of rare qualities. As he led us through the Dative and Ablative, the Vocative and Locative, he wove in personal anecdotes and fascinating philosophical ramblings from the 12th century.

During his stay in Oakland, Hoinacki was persuaded by Illich, Jerry Brown and other members of the symposium faculty, to teach an 8 a.m. Latin class. The class, free and open to all, was a big hit during the entire six-week session.

Hoinacki and I met to talk one afternoon near the end of the symposium in Mayor Brown’s well stocked library.

Richard Whittaker: As I’ve listened to these stories from your life the one thing that strikes me most is that there's been a genuine search in your life.

Lee Hoinacki: I think that’s true. I grew up in a small town. When I was in high school, I had a good time going out with my friends, going to dances—all that kind of thing. And after high school I wanted to go to college which was unusual in our town, and I was the first person in our family to go to college. Also I wanted to get out of this little town, Lincoln Illinois. But after high school, I decided I was too immature to go to college. I thought, this is something serious and I’ve been doing nothing but having a good time. The original G-I bill was in effect and I knew I could go into the service. There was a poster that said "Join The Marine Corps and See the World." I thought, well, maybe I’ll do that. So I signed up and they sent me to China immediately. I had just turned 18. I’d never traveled more than thirty miles. Also, I had a couple of other requirements. I didn’t want to accept a nickel from my father, and I wanted to be able to study full-time. And by cutting expenses I found I could live very easily on the G-I bill. So there was a kind of searching there. From then on it was more books and ideas, searching through a lot of reading and certain friends I made.

RW: I’ve been struck by some of the decisions you’ve made. You were in a doctoral program at UCLA when you left and moved to Venezuela. Had you completed your doctorate?

Hoinacki: I still had to write the dissertation. Within the first year of the university job I took when I got back, I wrote the dissertation.

RW: Okay. I was struck by the fact that your decision to leave the U.S. was a moral decision. This had something to do, I believe, with your seeing some of the Viet Nam war protests, etc.

Hoinacki: Seeing what the police were doing, and what the protesters were doing, was just a catalyst. I’d been out of the country for some years. I knew there was such a thing as the Viet Nam war, but seeing these things made me wonder, what’s going on? Why are they protesting? This was 1967, 1968 when I came back to this country from South America. So I started looking at this question of the war. Very quickly I came to the conclusion it was an unjust war - so totally unjust, that after a lot of reasoning, I came to the conclusion that I could not live in a country pursuing such a policy.

I just couldn’t do it. I felt a protest wasn’t enough. One had to say something stronger, and the strongest thing would be to exile myself from my own country. But this was not because of any police actions. Later on I came to the conclusion that it is very wrong to accuse the police of something. They are only instruments of those in power and are stuck in between.

RW: At any rate you left the country and went to Venezuela. There were a couple of people there who had an impact on your thinking.

Hoinacki: One a Spaniard, one an American. I met many Spaniards in Latin America who had gone into exile because they had been on the losing side in the Spanish civil war. They left for various reasons, fearing for their lives, not wanting to go to jail, or feeling they just couldn’t live under the regime of Franco. One of them, Pedro Grases, went to Venezuela. He’s still alive, very old. At that time in 1970-71, when I met him, he was very prestigious, the most learned and prominent historian in the country. In his private library he had gathered all the primary and secondary documents, as much as that was possible, for studying the history of Venezuela. His house was large and he had a separate structure on the grounds which housed his library.

I could talk a lot about this man, but it comes down to one conversation. We were alone in his library. He was expressing his personal feelings about his work and his life and so forth. He had been in Venezuela for thirty or forty years by this time, and he said to me, "You see my library, and you know what I’ve done. You see my life’s work. But who is going to carry on this work? My children are not interested in this kind of academic study. They’re interested in other things. I haven’t found anyone in Venezuela who wants to carry on this work."

He didn’t express it in so many words, but I felt this man looked on his life as a kind of failure. He hadn’t found anyone interested enough in their own history to carry on his work and he thought that the history of a people is so important for them. Venezuela is a very peculiar country, but I don’t need to go into that.

He was very European in terms of taking on protégés, students, disciples, and he had people who had come there to live and work with him like Raphael Caldera who became president of Venezuela.

Part of my dissertation had to do with studying Caldera and his friends. Caldera was a man who recognized immediately what Pedro Grases was doing and his importance to the country, his importance to the future of that nation. Caldera apprenticed himself to Grases as a student and lived there and worked with him. I don’t know how many years Caldera did that, but Caldera, of course, had a vocation to be a politician, and at a certain point he left Grases to enter politics. So there was Grases after some thirty years in Venezuela with a sense of failure.

Then I met an American, George Hall. George worked for the CREOLE foundation. At that time Venezuela had not yet nationalized their oil. It was owned by the Americans who had established the CREOLE Foundation to do things in Venezuela along the same lines as the Ford Foundation, to give money for educational and cultural projects, etc. George Hall was head of the foundation. He had been working in Venezuela for twenty or thirty years doing this, and I got to know him pretty well. I’d taken an academic research job there and part of my salary was coming from the CREOLE Foundation.

George took me to lunch one day and he talked about his life. He was getting ready to retire and return to America. George, reflecting on his life, talked about the tertulia. It’s a Spanish word for which we lack an equivalent in English, but it’s like a salon in which a kind of conversation and exchange takes place. These tertulias were organized by Pedro Grases and took place in his library. Pedro invited people to come in for conversation on Saturday mornings. I was also invited to come several times. At these meetings you would find leading figures of the country, an industrialist, a politician, top literary people, etc. Venezuela, in some ways, was a very insular society so that everyone "who counted" knew everyone else, and Pedro was able to bring them together. These people would sit down together in his library and have coffee. In the sessions I went to, all those invited were men. Women had not yet been included in that level of social, intellectual intercourse in Venezuela. I don’t know what is going on today.

What Pedro was able to do was to establish a certain level of what we call a civic conversation, creating in his own way the germ of a civil society. You have to know all of Venezuelan history to understand that, but it would take too long to go into all that.

Okay then, the whole point of the conversation with George was this—George said, "I go to these things—now I’ve been in Venezuela some thirty years! I go, and at these gatherings when the conversation reaches a certain point, a certain kind of issue, a curtain drops between all the Venezuelans and myself. I can feel it. There’s a quiet agreement not to discuss it any further. I’ve been cut out because I’m an American. Underneath everything there is a feeling: this guy is the American imperialist, etc."

So he felt, after living there some twenty years, that his life was a failure even though he had dedicated his life to educational and cultural projects for Venezuela.

At that time I was 39 or 40 and it made me stop and think. I’d come with a wife and two children and although I spoke the language well and was very well received by Venezuelans—I had no difficulty entering the society because look, there I was at the very top within a few weeks with the man who was the most important man in Venezuela intellectually—but I had to ask myself, wait a minute, what am I going to do twenty or thirty years down the line? Is my life going to be like George’s or Pedro’s? And so I thought that perhaps I’d made a mistake. Perhaps going into a different society is not such a good thing to do. Perhaps I should rethink my position.

RW: You decided to return to this country, but when you came back you needed a job. Your advisor at UCLA, I believe, told you he could get you a job in any university in the country. Yale. Harvard. So you thought that over. You looked around at the professors who had tenure in prestigious schools and decided you didn’t want that life, if I’ve heard you correctly. You eventually decided to take a position at one of a number of the new colleges and universities that were just springing up in that idealistic moment in the late sixties. Do I have that right?

Hoinacki: Yes.

RW: Now that’s another unusual decision, not to go to some place like Harvard where you would have had a good career path all laid out. You turned your back on consciously.

Hoinacki: Yes.

RW: So you became a faculty member at this new college and seven years later, when they initiated tenure there, you received tenure. And the day after you were given tenure you quit. You sold your house, cashed in your retirement fund, and made this radical decision to investigate the question of subsistence living. So you bought some land, 40 acres at the confluence of the Mississippi and the Ohio rivers. You must have been in your mid to late forties when you bought the land.

Hoinacki: I was exactly 50 years old.

RW: A series of very atypical decisions. Remarkable decisions. This is part of why I said it seemed to me that your life has been truly a search. I realize I’m trying to cover a lot of ground here. Maybe the question is, what can you say about this propensity you have, the courage to make such unusual life decisions?

Hoinacki: Of that I don’t know. You mention the word courage. That never occurred to me. I can’t recall exactly what I was thinking. It seemed to me that the university was not a good place for me to be. It seemed, from the ideas I’d picked up from Illich and from the books I’d read, that there was something really quite wrong about contemporary society, contemporary life.

For example, I got a letter from Theodore Kaczynski. I correspond with him. He enclosed a copy of a letter he’d sent to someone else to show me some of his thinking. The other person had said, "I don’t believe in killing people in respect to this opposition to technology." Kaczynski, in his letter, which was very carefully argued, said "I don’t know how much you understand about technology, so I’d like to suggest a couple of books to you." He was very polite in his letter. The books were both by Jacques Ellul, The Technological Society and The Autopsy of Revolution. Since receiving that letter I often get into situations where I’m talking about Kaczynski and talking about his document. I ask if they’ve ever heard of these two books. Of course in the circles where I move, they’ve all heard of The Technological Society, but not a single person had ever heard of Autopsy of Revolution. It was one of the textbooks I gave students to read.

I had been reading things like this which were really critical of what was going on in our society. Illich, for example, in his earlier years was attacked mercilessly by Marxists, because Marxism in Europe was a very respectable intellectual position. Many intellectuals in universities were Marxists. Illich’s criticisms have focused not on the owners of production, but on the mode of production. Illich understood something which Marx did not.

So I was reading these things and thinking about these matters and decided that this society is really in bad shape. The whole direction of the country, the whole way of doing things, of making things, of believing in things, the way of hoping for things, is all—to exaggerate a little bit—is all wrong. So therefore I asked, well, what is there?

Well, Illich had talked about the whole direction of modern life as what he called in a certain phrase, "a war against subsistence." What is subsistence? Is this something one just writes about in books that might have existed in some ancient time. Or is this something that has some kind of meaning today? Well, the only way to find out is to try it. You’re not going to find out reading books.

RW: A very important point. Most of us are just stuffed full of these things that come into the head, but they are never tested against experience. I think it’s unusual when someone does that in the ways you have. Not many people ever try that, but of course there are good reasons for that. People are just trying to get by, first of all.

Hoinacki: Right. As Thoreau pointed out in the very first pages of Walden, most people lead lives of quiet desperation -- trying to cope, trying to get through the day. You see this idea, which came up in America: Thank God It’s Friday! I mean, what a stupid idea, in a way! It’s not stupid, it’s sad. But that’s the real world.

RW: I have to ask how you view the acts that Kaczynski has done sending bombs through the mail to various individuals.

Hoinacki: When I first wrote to him, a rather long letter, I wrote about certain ideas that I thought were lacking in his Manifesto—I’m assuming he wrote it; he doesn’t admit that to this day, but that’s another story—certain ideas which were missing. I wrote it as a kind of open letter. Friends of mine saw it. People were very much upset with me in the university where I happened to be at that moment, Penn State University, and were really extremely critical with me for having any contact with someone they considered to be a murderer. So in an introduction, I said—with respect as to whether or not this man killed somebody—if he did, then we have appropriate measures in this country for trying people accused of murder. He should be subjected to that process, and if he is convicted, he should have to serve his time. I am very strongly against capital punishment. I don’t think it’s fitting and proper that the state take this kind of action.

Now whether he was guilty of sin, that’s only between him and God. As far as I can tell, he is a human being. Therefore I still have to respect him as a fellow human being. And since I think that what he wrote is something extremely valuable, very well thought out and coherent, and since I am interested in these subjects and presumably know something about them, that therefore I should try to contact him and engage him both as a human being and as someone whose thought I respect.

RW: The term "sin" that just appeared reminds me—I understand you are, or were, a Dominican priest. Are you currently still a Dominican priest?

Hoinacki: I don’t think one can erase that.

RW: Could tell us a little about that part of your life? I don’t know enough about the Roman Catholic church to know about the different orders. I know some of them are monastic.

Hoinacki: The Dominicans are a quasi-monastic order. A new invention of the 12th and 13th centuries. When I was in college one of the books that came to my attention was a book called The Seven Story Mountain by Thomas Merton. Books can have a very strong effect on me, and this was perhaps the first book that moved me in this very strong way. I had to ask the same questions that Merton asked. Merton studied scholastic philosophy and I said, I want to study that stuff too. So I checked around to see what the best places were to study scholastic philosophy in this hemisphere. The two places recommended to me were Laval University in Quebec and the Catholic University of America in Washington. I decided Catholic University was the safest one for me to choose and I went there.

While I was there I looked at this question of the priesthood and the Dominicans looked attractive to me. They seemed to emphasize an intellectual life and they had a big house across the street from where I was living, so I walked over there and introduced myself and talked to them and I decided that yes, this is where I wanted to go.

One of the Dominicans there talked with me over a period of a year and then said, okay. But all the classes were in Latin. I didn’t know Latin. So I had to enroll in a special course in Providence, Rhode Island where I studied Latin for a year. Then there were three years of what they called philosophy. And then four years of theology. Afterwards I became a priest and was assigned to New York City. From New York I was assigned to go to Chile in South America.

RW: Now all of this comes before you were at UCLA?

Hoinacki: Yes. In the meantime I’d met Illich in 1960 while I was in New York City working on E. 68th St. at a church there. I found there were lots of people I had to deal with who spoke Spanish. I didn’t know a word of Spanish. So I looked around and found that the best place to learn Spanish, if you really wanted to work at it, was at a place in Puerto Rico. As it turned out it had been set up by Ivan Illich, and that is where I met him. I returned to New York City in 1962 and heard a rumor that the Dominicans were going to send me to Chile. I thought, I’d better take my vacation before they sent me. I knew that Illich had gone to Mexico, so I went down to see what he was doing. Illich asked, before I left, if I’d come and work with him. I told him I would if my superiors would assign me there. I was convinced he was doing good work. Illich said, okay, "I’ll arrange that."

The Dominicans did send me to Chile. In the meantime, Illich started working on my superiors to get them to assign me to Mexico. They resisted him, but Illich is not someone to be deterred. He went to Rome because he had contacts there. He was educated in the seminary there and said, "I’m going to the Pope if necessary." First he went to the head of the Dominicans, a Spaniard named Suarez, and said, "I want this man assigned to me." Illich is a Roman Catholic priest who was working under Cardinal Spellman. Spellman supported Illich’s work until the day Spellman died.

Anyway, every year or two Suarez would go all over the world checking to see how things were going with the various Dominicans and he told Illich, I’m going to Chile in a couple of weeks and I’ll talk to this guy. He did, and he called me in. He introduced himself as the Master General and asked me what I knew about Illich’s work. I told him what I thought of it and he said, "Okay, pack you bags and go."

So I packed my bags and went to Mexico and worked with Illich there for three years. Then I decided to marry. I had no argument with the priesthood, with the Dominicans, with Illich, with anything except I wanted to marry.

It was a confusing time. I wondered, should I leave Mexico? stay? What should I do? Illich said, if you’re going to get married, you’re going to have a wife to support. That means you’re going to need a job. To get a job you’re going to need a piece of paper. The piece of paper is called a PhD. He was just confirming what I already knew. I decided to get a PhD.

Illich had met all the people who were heads of Latin American studies departments in U. S. universities. They had all met in Cuernavaca for their annual convention, and Illich had gotten to know them all. He told me there was only one guy he really respected, Johannes Wilbert. Illich had the idea you study under some individual, not in a school or a department. The institution doesn’t count, it’s the person who counts, a European idea. Wilbert was at UCLA.

The woman I wanted to marry lived in San Pedro near Los Angeles. I asked her to arrange an appointment and she did. I walked into Wilbert’s office and told him I wanted to get a PhD. I told him that Illich had told me he was the man I should see in the U.S. He said, okay.

He hadn’t seen a single record or test I’d done. He hadn’t seen anything. He was taking Illich’s word alone. I didn’t even have a letter. He just took my word for it. He was a remarkable man, and we’re still very dear friends.

I got married and my wife got a job teaching. We got by somehow. I finished the degree, but while I was at UCLA I decided I had to go to Venezuela.

RW: I see. Let's jump forward in time. You’d gone to Venezuela and returned. You’d already left the university where you’d been teaching for seven years. You’d gotten the land and had already been doing subsistence farming for a few years. Then you decided you needed to supplement your farm income. Jobs were not easy to find where you were living. You ended up with a position as a kitchen helper in a university dining hall, is that right? To get that job you had to withhold a lot of information, that you’d been a college professor, a priest and so on.

Hoinacki: I had been getting along all right on the farm for a number of years, but I needed the extra money to help out my daughter who was going to college. So I first went down to the university where I already had adjunct faculty status because I’d wanted to use their library. They’d been willing to give me that and I thought maybe they’d let me teach one course a semester, but nothing was available. Then I looked around the university to see if there were any other academic jobs, "respectable jobs," but that didn’t work out.

Then it hit me, why am I trying to get one of these respectable kinds of jobs? That’s the wrong way to go. I came to see, this is ridiculous! I shouldn’t be trying to get a respectable job. That’s the worst thing I could do! That’s what I left years ago! So then I got the kitchen job.

RW: You said that this kitchen job, which was just simple labor, left you totally free to think while carrying out your tasks, and that you used this free time to think. Most people would have been daydreaming. But because of your training as a Dominican, I take it, you had learned how to think in an intentional way. I think you called it "recollection." It strikes me as a very unusual thing.

Hoinacki: Within the western Christian tradition there is an idea—today some writers use the word "mindfulness"—but some writers still stick with the old word, "recollection." The idea is that one is always recollected. It has to do with the concept of what it is to be human. This comes out of Aristotle, and then secondly from the scholastics of which Thomas Aquinas who died in 1274, is the pinnacle. These people said you must be able to act humanly, which means one should use one’s reason and think about what you’re doing. One should be able to choose the good action from among your alternatives.

They have a theory about "habits and virtues." What is habit, what is virtue? If you don’t think about what you should do, you automatically do whatever your habit has inclined you to do. You automatically fall into that.

If a person lives what Plato and Socrates call "a reflective life, an examined life" one will always be thinking. Since I come out of that tradition, I agree with that and I’ve tried to practice that kind of thing. So it was very easy for me to practice this kind of thinking while I was washing dishes. What else did I have to do? That’s the way I trained my mind to work.

RW: If I’m following you—part of this is that you are actually examining some of your thinking habits. You would not want to be thinking "automatically," right? If you see what I’m driving at.

Hoinacki: Yes. See, what you would do is you would always have certain ideas or themes or notions that you would want to think about. You don’t just "think in general." I would go to work each day with some particular point I would want to think about, some idea, some specific news item or something I’d read the night before. You would always have to be very specific and very concrete about that.

RW: Eventually you sold your farm. You sold it for, I believe you said, one third of the assessed value. Not only did you sell it for this extremely low price, but then you carried the mortgage yourself at no interest! These are remarkable decisions. I wonder if you would say a few words about that.

Hoinacki: Originally my intention was to give it away. I felt that in my life I’d been given a lot, that I’ve been a very privileged and fortunate person. I’d been given a free education all the way through. I’d been given very good parents. I’ve had good friends—people like Illich, like Wilbur at UCLA. My wife and I have two lovely children—can’t imagine anyone having more decent, good children. They’re grown now. I had a wonderful life with my wife, and so I felt it was not right to take money.

I thought, well, I’ve lived pretty well without money until now, and I can probably find something to support myself, because I’d become accustomed to getting along without much money. I’d had the experience of this kitchen-helper job and thought, I can work at a job like that. So I was going to give it away, but I decided against that, not because my children opposed that—they said, "sure, give it away if that’s what you want to do!"—but because it wouldn’t be fair to them if I didn’t sell it for something. They would have the expense of burying me when I die, and I hadn’t given much to them anyway, just a pittance to my daughter. So I thought, I should sell it for something, but how much? Maybe a third would be okay. I think it came to around twenty thousand dollars—way, way under the assessed value.

Not charging interest was also important to me. I’ve studied the history of interest in the West. Of course that begins in the Hebrew scriptures. At any rate, I found I couldn’t accept taking interest. On this type of loan I felt it would be usury. Why did I need the interest? I could justify interest under some conditions, of course. If it were a hardship to me, for instance. But if it’s no hardship, how could I accept making money for not doing any work? I don’t think one should receive money for not doing some kind of work.

RW: You’ve described yourself as a Thomist, but "not a straight-backed Thomist" as you put it. What is it that attracted you to his thought?

Hoinacki: Well, I think it’s very important to stand within a tradition. I don’t think one can make up one’s own philosophy, that is, just from starting to think. The difficulty of that is shown by Wittgenstein. He, in a sense, tried to do that. Descartes also tried to do that. They thought that the old tradition didn’t make sense any more and they had good reasons for thinking that. You can see why Descartes’ efforts failed. And for very different reasons, Wittgenstein’s efforts failed. You have to go into that and it would be a long complicated thing. So it seems to me one needs to stand within a tradition.

I was born a Roman Catholic and, in this western tradition, there are various intellectual currents within it or associated with it. Some people would argue that the main current is associated with Scholasticism and its exemplary figure is Aquinas. Not all would agree. I have looked at the history of western thought both through primary documents and secondary documents, and it seems to me that, in this western tradition, the most coherent, the most sensible, the most intellectually respectable set of ideas are represented by this guy Aquinas. I think one can go beyond him, and he leaves openings in such a way that one can extend his thought without abandoning it.

Right now, here in Oakland I’m teaching a course, six days of the week, one hour a day, on Latin. We take a text of Aquinas and we go through that text word by word. What they’re finding is that they’re intrigued. They show up every morning, never miss. I’ve never done this before, but I find it’s a tremendous pleasure. What I’m finding is that I’m further convinced of the coherence and the truth of the way this guy proceeds and what he has to say.

RW: You remarked at one point that if you could help undermine the idea of progress, you’d be pleased with that—this unexamined faith we have in the idea of progress.

Hoinacki: Yes.

RW: I wonder if you think that in Aquinas’ time there may have been understandings which were actually more informed, more grounded, in essential human realities that we have today?

Hoinacki: Not only is that true, but it was perhaps a different kind of reality than we have today. That’s why some people think you can not use this philosophy because, for example, he was basing himself on Aristotelian biology. Since biologists no longer accept that, the tendency would be to assume that the philosophical reasoning based on that biology also does not hold water today. There are two considerations here. One, is his thought historically contingent? There’s no doubt about that. In a different age one would have thought differently, and one thinks differently today. On the other hand, his thought represents a certain way of thinking. If I were to go into the East I’d find a whole different way of thinking, of conceptualizing what is the universe, what is a person.

I feel I have to root myself in my own tradition, to get my feet on a ground. I feel the only ground that is safe for me is this ground, not some Eastern ground which will always be, as translated through westerners, superficial or dilettantish. I’m exaggerating a little bit there, it may not always be, but that’s the danger. Not for Easterners, of course, but for westerners.

So it seems to me that it’s very easy to spot where Aquinas is basing himself, for instance, on Aristotelian biology and to what extent that is perhaps not the best way to conceptualize biology, not that present biology is the final word. Nevertheless it seems to me that Aquinas’ thought is still coherent in terms of his basic notions of how the mind works, and how human beings act. I don’t think that Freud’s work, and those that come out of that tradition, in any way destroys Aquinas. What they do is show that you may have to take into account the unconscious. You may have to take into account repression, transference, etc. But I don’t see how this destroys the basic thought of Aquinas.

RW: Do you think that in Aquinas’s time there was, in general—among people at large—a better connection with feeling functions and with the body and sensation?

Hoinacki: I think that’s quite evident. I think that’s evident in any study of texts of these various years. From the time of Descartes on, if you could name a time or a person, people and the west have had increasing difficulty in being in contact with their own bodies. And of course, Illich is involved in trying to think through and write about this. What he calls the dis-enfleshment of people. The dis-embodiment of people. Whether you want to talk about something like "virtual reality" —I mean, where’s the flesh in virtual reality? They talk about chat rooms on the internet. Chat rooms? Chat only can happen when I can look into your eyes and see how you’re moving your head at this moment. If I want to call Internet communication "chat," I’m deceiving myself. I’m starting to live by certain kinds of illusions which, of course, I think the contemporary world is full of.

There are illusions in the middle ages, of course, but on this specific point they were much more in touch with reality than we are, meaning many people today.

RW: I was struck by something you described in your book, El Camino. [A journal Hoinacki kept on his walking pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela] You were walking and suddenly realized that you were truly present - present to yourself and where you were, actually in touch with everything around you in a way that’s hard to describe. You wrote that you’d never experienced it before, in fact, and you were 65 years old at the time. I wonder if you’d say something about that.

Hoinacki: I think the entire question of experience is infinitely penetrable. There’s no end to what one can experience in terms of depth. I’m firmly convinced, especially from my experience in Spain, that the entire question of experience is really not understood, not explored, not experienced. You read the anthropological literature about liminal experience and those kinds of ideas, and you say, ahh, there’s more to experience than just living a kind of surface life, a kind of washed out life.

I do believe that much in the world around each one of us is designed against experience. For example, the experience of actually touching the soil. How many times do we actually take off our shoes and walk on the dirt? What do different kinds of soil feel like? How many times do we even open the windows? I’ve been in buildings where you have no experience of any kind of air except this artificial stuff that is blown in through vents.

There are so many ways every day that we, namely many people, deprive ourselves of experience. We no longer even know how to take advantage of what is possible, just like people don’t know how to take advantage of leisure, for example. How to use experience? How to walk out and feel the air, to see the sky, the trees, how they’re changing, to experience the person in front of you? I have the impression from my own experience that so much has been washed out of me.

RW: On your pilgrimage, your 1000 kilometer walk, you made these two rules: not to read anything about this famous pilgrimage, and always to walk alone. I take it you wanted to keep the room for your own experience entirely open.

Hoinacki: Well, I didn’t think of it that way exactly. I’d gone to Compostela earlier and had been at the cathedral. I’d sat there for several hours in a quiet little chapel trying to think, why in the world do people come here? I wondered because I could see nothing that would pull me to this place. But I knew that hundreds of thousands, maybe millions, had walked there since the eighth or ninth centuries. So it occurred to me that the only way I could ever find out why anyone came there would be to do it myself.

I would have to enter into the experience of these people somehow. And how could I do that? Because everything is so different today. Well, I have two legs, and the air in some way is the same and, to a certain extent, the earth had not changed. In some places there was paving, but the mud was the same, the dirt was the same, the rain was the same, and the sky is much the same. If I were to enter that air and walk under that sky, I thought that perhaps I could enter into something like whatever those people experienced. Then perhaps I could find out why these people did this. I didn’t think anything about all this sense experience. I didn’t realize that was going to happen.

And instead of sitting around reading books about it I decided to read nothing on the subject before I went. I didn’t want to fill up my mind with some writer’s ideas. Later on, after I’d done it myself, I read those accounts. Then I could see, this account rings true and that one doesn’t, or this guy saw something interesting which I missed.

RW: You called that experience of presence you described earlier an exemplar, and said that we need exemplars.

Hoinacki: I think this is true in all kinds of areas. For instance, it’s absolutely necessary to have human exemplars whether it was the Greeks reading Homer and looking at the exemplary persons in the Illiad and the Odyssey, or the Christians reading The Lives of the Saints.

And I think it’s necessary in terms of exemplary experiences. If you‘ve never loved another person very intensely, for instance, you’re not going to know what love is. Now that’s a very problematic thing because historically all kinds of influences come in. Notions of love at any specific moment in Western society can be really very questionable, let us say. If you’ve never experienced what it is to have a really really good and intimate friend and have been able to share that friendship, your life not only is emptier, but you have no way to judge other people. You’re really at sea.

You need exemplary experiences of place, of thought, of clear thought. Why? It’s just that there are a lot of bad teachers around, and a lot of bad books—a lot of bad examples. If you really get into, say, thought and into prayer—you could come to someone like Plotinus, a late Greek philosopher who goes into the experience of God somehow. He was a Pagan but very attractive to Christian thinkers because of the way his thought went.

But there is a certain problem with Greek thought. I think there’s a certain overemphasis on intellect, but that’s another historical question.

RW: I’m tempted to ask more about that, but I wanted to touch a little on Simone Weil. I was just reading her last night. There’s this one thing she said which I think is amazing: "There are two forces in the universe: gravity and light." Do you want to say anything about that?

Hoinacki: Yes. I find her a difficult author, but in many ways the most attractive author of all the people I’ve read. She also is one of the authors I used when I was teaching at the university. The students have enormous difficulty in reading her texts. But I stuck with her. There is much that I don’t understand and that is not understandable unless you are able to experience the prayer life that she experienced, which was not only unique in terms of its depth or height, but unique in terms also of her person. She was so different from every other woman around in France at that time, and of every other person in her own circle—utterly different! The way she dressed, the way she talked, the way she acted. Everything about her. So it becomes enormously difficult, not only to read her work, but to understand what she is saying.

She says "now and then I get insights into what I think is a reality that I think no one else has ever said." For example, I have an essay on my desk which I always carry with me. She asks, how can one come to respect the other? How is it possible to respect another person?

She said, there is only one way to do that. In every person there is some inclination, something deep in that person - we would say, "deep in that person’s heart" - that goes out towards infinite good, absolute good. That is how everyone is made.

The fact that there is on this earth any good at all, any truth at all, is because someone has gotten into contact with this. In that way a person is somehow inspired to know what is good and true - that is, through this kind of contact - which is in every person.

Every person is capable of this, and that’s why I have to respect this other person, because that potential contact with infinite good is in there. That is the only reason I can respect that other person. The only reason. All these other reasons—nonsense! she says. None of that other stuff holds up.

When I’m in America I don’t go by airplane, I only travel by bus. There are various reasons for that. I meet people I would never ordinarily meet. I would never see these people on this earth if I were not on a bus—so-called poor people, people at the bottom. Some of them are not very pleasant. The poor are not always pleasant people, and I will find myself faced with the question, how can I respect this person? There I find Simone Weil ultimately practical. If I can not see that inclination in that person for good, I can never come to respect that person. If I can’t see that, then I’m lost.

[Phil Berryman's reflections at Lee Hoinacki's memorial service. Hoinacki died Feb. 28, 2014 - a remarkable man.]

Jay Irwin

Jan. 24, 2026: Dear Mr Cayley, My name is Jay Irwin, and I'm a philosophy professor at Corpus Christi College in Vancouver. It's a great pleasure to finally have a good reason to write to you. I have been a great fan of your work for so many years—decades. Indeed, I'd say your work played a large role in my first decisions to study philosophy. You acquainted me with important thinkers early on who have never left my side: Illich, Grant, Weil, the Radical Orthodoxy group, and many others.

The reason I write is that our college (specifically me and the dean, Paul Allen) are in the early phases of organizing a conference on George Grant. It would not be a large gathering, but will seek to bring together Grant experts and amateur enthusiasts to discuss his work. The tentative theme will be a focus on Grant's theology, but the direction one takes on that theme can of course be loose.

Attracting you to such a conference would be a treat for everybody present. In fact, I'm sure many of the younger scholars will, like myself, have come alive to Grant through your work. We're still in preliminary phases, as I mentioned, but this email is to merely reach out and see if you have any interest, and if so, if you might be free in October/November of this year?

Thank you for taking the moment to read and consider this. P.S. And I am very much enjoying your new book on the CBC. 

——

Jan.26, 2026, from David: Thanks for your letter.  It made me happy to hear of your connection to my Ideas work, and also to know that you are reading the CBC book.  I'm getting pretty old and travel only sparingly, but I'm interested to hear of your conference and wouldn't rule out participating altogether at this stage, so do keep me informed.  I imagined George Grant smiling at the thought of his being discussed as a theologian. 

——

May 8, 2026, from Jay: My deepest apologies. I felt in such connection to you as I read your CBC book (a wonderful education, by the way) that I must have overlooked entirely that I did not respond to this!  I do hope you'll forgive me.

We have firmed up dates for the Grant Seminar next year. Feb 12-13 2027. It will be a small, intimate gathering of scholars with a particular interest in Grant. There will be two lunches and a dinner. Our tentative title for the seminar is "George Grant and the Human Spirit," a title that we hope brings in a broad range of interests.

Again, we would be incredibly honoured if you attended. Dr. Paul Allen and I think, too, that if you were to attend, we would love to have you deliver the final remarks. Let me know if that sounds at all interesting.

——

May 10, 2026, from David: I remain tempted but unlikely for your February conference, but I'm enthusiastic about meeting up while you're here in Toronto in August, so consider yourself invited to lunch at my place on some convenient day which we can determine later.

——

May 10, 2026, from Jay: Thank you for having considering the conference. Even in your absence, I'm sure you'll be quoted and footnoted often.


May 21, 2026: Subject: "Subdued Brilliance: Life and Order in the Cosmic Vision of Christopher Alexander"
From Jay to David: I've just had a book accepted at Wipf and Stock (in the Veritas Series, under their Cascade imprint), written on the architectural and design theorist Christopher Alexander. For the past few weeks, I've been humming and hawing about who I might ask to possibly offer endorsements for the insert, and I've just realized that I've had the rare and recent luck of being in touch with one of my greatest unofficial teachers—David Cayley!

It's not an out-of-the-blue solicitation either, in that I'd say Alexander fits the mold of many of the sort of thinkers you seek to bring from the margins into more popular consideration. In fact, I see Alexander as someone of a deeply counter-intuitive sensibility, a thinker I believe you'll like--in the spirit of Grant or Weil or Illich. In fact, his work might be seen as a companion piece with Illich's work on the concept of "dwelling".

And just a note, an endorsement for the book does not depend on any sort of deep architectural knowledge.  As I make clear in the introduction, it's a work of philosophy. If I were to sum it up, it's a philosophy on the art of vernacular building (and perhaps the processes of any art) as well as a metaphysics of "life" or a "living world".

In any case, I would love if you would take a moment to read the introduction to see if it might interest you. If it doesn't, or if it doesn't fit your schedule (the final draft is scheduled for Sept 1), please do not hesitate to say no. Thank you for taking the time.  And either way, I still look forward to meeting you in-person when I'm in Toronto this August.

——

May 25, 2026, from David: Despite my old esteem for Christopher Alexander, and my budding esteem for you, I began my reading of your introduction in the hope of finding a reason to say no to your request.  I just have so much to do - at least by my somewhat relaxed octogenarian standards.  However, I could discover no reason, and instead found many overlappings with my own reflections at the moment.  So, yes, if I have 'til September, I will read your book, and write something about it.
——

May 25, 2026, from Jay: I really don't know how to thank you. This is such wonderful news. Your name has great weight in the circles I travel in, and will attract the very sort of readers I hope to draw to the book, readers similar to myself!  And I shouldn't be surprised that you're familiar with Alexander! That you'd fit me into your schedule means so much, David.
——

Excerpts from Jay Irwin’s Christopher Alexander Book

——

Sept.21, 2026, to Jay: This is Jutta writing, David Cayley's wife (now widow). I don't know if you heard that David died on June 10, not long after his last email to you. He was playing music with some friends, at our house,  and his heart stopped in the middle of a song. 

That was a different kind of heartbreaker for me and our families, and yet there's a lot to be grateful for. 

I'm still going through his emails and just found yours this morning. And then the George Grant conference thread as well. 

It happens that I have been a Christopher Alexander enthusiast for a long time, and David got me some of the early books as birthday presents. David even interviewed him once, sometime in the 1980s, during a family road trip in California, at Alexander's out-in-a-field office, while I and our then-young kids waited outside, with the kids jumping on and off a low wall (of course). That interview never went anywhere. But I'm not surprised that you've written a book that's a philosophy on the art of vernacular building (and perhaps the processes of any art) as well as a metaphysics of "life" or a "living world."  I've downloaded the draft you sent him and look forward to reading it. 

I have a request. Would it be okay with you if I post the relevant sections of your correspondence, and also make a link to your book when it's published? 

Sept.21, 2026, from Jay: There is nothing that would give me more pleasure. Please use whatever you would like of our correspondence. I'm exceedingly honoured to be included on the website.

I heard about David's passing during the summer and have actually been composing emails to you in my mind ever since. What a wonderful surprise to see this note. I attended a faculty birthday party a few evenings ago and David came up more than a few times in conversation. One of the comments from one of the professors was that David had "educated an entire generation." I very much agree with that. The amount of thinkers his programme and books exposed me too really seem to be all the thinkers that still matter most to me—Illich, Grant, Weil. I found an old foxed copy of his "Conversations with Northrop Frye" this summer (in an old tinker, antiques, and used book shop in Port Carling) and so enjoyed it. I'm also currently re-listening to his Charles Taylor Ideas episodes. It's an endless trove.

Michael Sauter

Mar 22, 2023, from Mike Sauter: Hey David-- I hope you are doing well. Michael and I would love to have you back on the podcast sometime if you are open to it. I'd really like to propose that we talk to you and promote something that interests you but there's no shortage of topics that I can think of, too. Let me know if you're interested sometime.

I'm writing today because I've just finished a short series of three articles for Front Porch on the future of the Church, wherein I examine the shortcomings of "religion" when it’s cast as being the most apt container for the message of the Gospel. You are present in all of them but, by name, most present in the last one.

Lately, too, I've been thinking about friendship and how, in "Philosophy, Artifacts and Friendship" Illich pointed out how the 60's generation thirsted for "justice" and the young people he was teaching towards the end of his life thirsted for, even though they could not necessarily understand the references in Aelred and others, this relationship, or 'way' or 'state'. Anyhow, David, I just wanted to send along these relatively short pieces (below) as you might find them interesting as your work in Illich really got me thinking more about "religion".

https://www.frontporchrepublic.com/2022/04/spiritual-but-not-religious-revisited-an-urgent-case-for-the-psychiatric/

https://www.frontporchrepublic.com/2022/08/a-case-for-the-psychiatric-part-2-dostoevskys-christianity/

https://www.frontporchrepublic.com/2023/03/deeper-than-religion-with-powys-and-chesterton/

——

Mar 25, 2023, from David: Thanks for your three essays which I got a chance to read yesterday. I won't attempt a commentary here. You must know that the direction your thinking is taking largely agrees with mine. However, I was introduced to several thinkers and writers I know little or nothing about. The most intriguing was Powys - the English Dostoevsky being pretty high praise in my ears. If I wanted to get to know his work, where would you recommend that I start? I was also very touched by your heart for the young. Jutta and I have our grandchildren in mind in a very similar way.

I thoroughly enjoyed talking to you and Michael last time and will gladly do it again whenever you like. My current work is a book the the CBC and public broadcasting more generally, in which I consider where the CBC has got to over the going-on ninety years of its existence, and where it might go under radically revised assumptions. There are certainly topics there concerning the media and discourse environment in which we're living, but it would also be interesting to talk about the meaning of religion along the lines you've been exploring.

——

March 27, 2023, from Mike: I am so grateful you suffered my series of articles as I figured you would at least understand the basic critique and movement. In the Fall I was asked by my Bishop to run my local parish again and that's been interesting, especially in light of the path my thinking has taken. As for Powys, it is such a large and unwieldy corpus, but also so fruitful, and his book on Rabelais and a book called "In Spite of" are both decent intros. "Mortal Strife" (with the 'change of fascism' I recommend in my article) and an odd but charming book called "The Art of Growing Old" both have really important insights in this area as well.

And, yes, the mental health crisis of young adults is totally central for me right now.

Before I wrote to you, Michael was thinking we needed to do a deeper dive on Simone Weil. Maybe we could do an episode on her thought and maybe merge it into this direction on the meaning of religion you and I are exploring? Just the example of her "On the Right Use of School Studies.." takes us pretty far down this road. Thinking maybe sometime in the week after Easter.

I'd also like to do one on your book as it would be a good focus for a wider discussion on the recent history of the media.

——

April 6 2023, from David: Friday the 14th with you and Michael on Simone Weil and the future of religion is a date. I hope you're thinking of it more as a conversation than an interview, given the thought you've recently put in to this question.

Thanks for the Powys article. I'm looking forward to reading it, even if it does invite me to swim in a bog.

Just finished The Sovereignty of Good. I did read one of Murdoch's novels years ago, but her thought was essentially new to me, so there's a lot to take in.

——

Jul 9, 2025, from Mike: I hope and trust all is well with you and yours. I know you've been spending time editing/finishing your book on the CBC but that ERH essay came out of nowhere for me, but it's such a game changer and I'm in my second reading of his The Christian Future, and it's causing me to rearrange, or at least adjust, a lot of mental furniture. Thank you so much for introducing him to me, as he was just a name I barely recognized a few weeks ago.

Any interest in coming back on the podcast sometime soon to discuss him and the CBC and more? We'd love to have you. I'd like to draw as much attention to your essay as possible. Michael is distributing veggies from his CSA on most Saturdays so we've been thinking about weeknights more, (after we took a month or so off).

Thanks again, David, for continuing to be an adventurer as that has helped me a lot.

——

Jul 11, 2025 from David: I'm just delighted to hear that my attempt at introducing Rosenstock-Huessy to a wider audience was of interest to you - even better that you're on a second reading of The Christian Future - the book that drew me in. I wrote the essay mainly to clarify my own mind - as a step from entertaining his ideas as an enthusiastic and sympathetic reader to seeing if I was able to reproduce his argument in black and white, so to speak. Talking to you and Michael, would be another step, and so long as you're willing to take the lead and share your reading, I'd be happy to do another conversation for the podcast. Early August would be better for me than right away, as I am just working my way into a new theme - comparing Illich's account of "the mystery of evil" with Carl Jung's attempted revision of Christianity in his late works Aion and Answer to Job - and will need to keep my mind on that for a couple of weeks.

——

Jul 16, 2025 from Mike: Your project with Jung and Illich sounds interesting! Cristado is great on Rosenstock, so thanks for recommending his work as well as your own, as I feel like to do need something of a map for him, though I find him immediately sympatico because of his focus on time. I forget which essay, but I've always remembered Illich as saying we have police-type forces for space, but not for "time". But, even with that temporal-view, it's seems that Christado is saying that his singular difference is that he focuses on the "end" whereas thinkers like Agamben focus on the "messianic". I'm still reading my way into a better sense for that divide. But I just love the way Rosenstock plows forward and I'm listening to a 3-part series of talks he gave on the Peace Corps, recorded by his students at Dartmouth. Anyhow, thanks again for singling him out!

I look forward to talking sometime in early August. I'll have Michael read your essay but I will prepare some conversation topics that bring in Rosenstock and your thoughts and, as always, it will just lead into a deeper conversation that will go wherever the Holy Spirit takes us.

——

Aug 16, 2025, from Mike: I hope you are well, and that your work on Jung continues apace. I see from our correspondence that I had targeted being back in touch with you regarding a podcast on Rosenstock in 'early August', but here we are. My apologies for falling behind. Michael and I have been kind of hit-and-miss with podcasts for the past couple of months but are gearing up a bit moving into September. Last week, I mentioned on our podcast that, soon, we'd be talking to you, (a fan favorite), about Rosenstock and that people should read your essay. From that mention, I heard from a talented thinker and writer, Caryl Johnson, who shared her essay on ERH: https://theimaginativeconservative.org/2024/06/eugen-rosenstock-huessy-cross-reality-caryl-johnston.html

I thought it might be fun for the four of us, (you, Michael, Caryl and myself) to chat about him. Does this work for you? I'm looking forward to this conversation and I hope all is well with you and yours, David. I thought we'd also possibly talk about Wendell Berry a bit, too. But we'll see where it goes.

Henry Zhu

Nov 12, 2025 from Henry:
I've been slowly adding to my own personal archive similar to the davidtinapple one.

——

Nov 17, 2025, from David: Your Illich archive is very good, and has a bunch of things that can't be found either at Tinapple or at Silja's Pudel site.  Good for you.
  ——

Nov 17, 2025, from Henry: Thanks David! Yeah I tried finding some archives from various databases. I know there's an archival project going on and got connected to it (though they didn't respond back yet)…

Oct 12, 2026, Henry to Jutta: I was devastated to hear the news. I was actually attending the annual Thinking with Ivan Illich 2026 in Lucca, Italy (thanks to David I was able to meet Nicola and learn about the events). […] Looks like our first email was 12/21/21, calls were 1/14/22, 1/27/23, 2/24/25, 11/25/25! Yes https://henryzoo.com/illich is my archive!
Also, it would be my pleasure to help with the website in any way possible if that would be useful for you, whether on the backend/managing data/content/writing, the visuals/organization, or even hosting. (having a professional software engineer background). I would love to share more of David's work, especially with the podcast/ideas. What I want to do with my illich archive and maybe davids's is full text search so you can find a statement/quote from any of the podcasts, or other features like connecting references/links, etc. In a similar way to my own podcast transcripts and more (https://hopeinsource.com/history). I think I may also still have another recording I never posted too..

——

——

Anna Sjöberg

Nov 7, 2025 Anna Sjöberg wrote: Dear David Cayley, My name is Anna Sjöberg. I am a researcher in Systematic Theology in Sweden (Uppsala university), and am currently working on a postdoc project on Ivan Illich, with the title ”A New Way of Doing Theology: Christianity, Secularization and Modernity in the Thought of Ivan Illich”. Together with two colleagues, Isabella Bruckner (Pontificio Ateneo Sant’Anselmo, Rome) and Gemma Serrano, we are organizing a conference in Rome 14 – 16 May, 2026, with the working title ”Corruptio optimi quae est pessima”, revolving around The Rivers North of the Future and the ”hypothesis” he presents to all of us there, to continue, to think-with.  

The aim of this workshop / conference is to do precisely this, to test his hypothesis, to examine how this can be done today and what we can bring to it, while commemorating and celebrating the 100 years that have passed since Illich was born. Your latest, beautiful book is of course an invaluable contribution, and an important source in my own work. We would be delighted if you would accept an invitation to take part in this conference, in presence or online. My suggestion would be that you give a talk around your book, but you would be free to bring up any topic related to this theme, if you have currently moved on to something new that you would like to discuss with us.   

We are still in the planning phase, and are at present interested to hear if you would be interested and have the possibility to attend. Other invited participants will be persons from different parts of Europe working mostly in the fields of theology and philosophy and on Illich in some way, and also Fabio Milana, who is currently working on the publication of the complete works of Illich in Italian (which you probably know) and Giorgio Agamben. We are in the process of sending out invitations, and have no fixed list of speakers yet.

With the hope for a continued dialogue, also beyond the occasion of this conference,

——
Nov 8, 2025, from David: Dear Anna,  I'm delighted to hear of your planned conference, and equally of your own work.  I wouldn't rule it out absolutely - never say never - but I'm getting pretty old and infirm and travel only sparingly, so some kind of on-line involvement on my part is, unhappily, much more likely.  

         It would be wonderful if you could get Giorgio and Fabio involved.  Someone else I thought of, and perhaps you are in touch already, is Barbara Hallensleben at the University of Fribourg and her student Anna Heidelk.  Barbara organized a conference on Illich a couple of years ago - I think the papers are to be published eventually - and Anna has subsequently taken an active part in the annual gathering of the Illich conspiracy that Sajay Samuel organizes.  Sajay - along with other friends also edits the associated journal, Conspiratio, and deals with publications.

         I wish you could luck with your organizing.   

——

Dec 3, 2025, from Anna:

I will attach here also the sketch of our description of what we are hoping to do together in May (in French, Italian and English). It is not yet a finished document, but it will give you a hint of what we seek to achieve.

TITLE:

CORRUPTIO OPTIMI QUAE EST PESSIMA

PROPOSED SUBTITLES:

Illich’s Method
A Repertoire of Theological Gestures
Creative Tactics for Disrupting Corruptions

ARGUMENT

In his conversations with David Cayley, Illich repeatedly asserts that “modernity can be studied as an extension of the history of the Church” and that “the modern world becomes intelligible only as a perversion of the Christian message” (Rivers North of the Future, 2003).
This claim is not a polemical diagnosis nor an hypothesis derived from historical or philological exercises; it points instead to a 
distinctive theological method.

Illich undertakes a genealogy of evangelical corruption: charity transformed into administered service; hospitality into hospitalization; care into sanitary management; teaching into compulsory schooling; mission into development, and so forth. He exposes the perversions of the sacred order, unveils the mechanisms of collective deception, speaks against the stabilizing dispositifs of institutions, and seeks to restore perception by revealing what the system has rendered invisible.

His vocabulary is not normative; it aims at reshaping perception. His method is not a program but a gestural and embodied practice. It consists in: stripping words bare; identifying thresholds of inversion; disenchanting perception; defending the vernacular; converting the gaze; speaking from the margins; inventing counter-conducts; analysing sensory regimes; and recognizing the wounds produced by institutional operations.

These gestures belong to the ascetic and prophetic dimensions of theology. They return theology to its humus, to the fragile, risky, embodied event that grounds it. They provide resources for resisting forms of domination that present themselves as the fulfilment of the good.

At this point, a series of questions becomes unavoidable:
Where are the vernacular spaces today—those places where one can still live without being administered?
What kind of theology might emerge from such spaces, and not from offices, dispositifs, or committees?
How can one resist when resistance itself risks being captured, recuperated, or integrated?
What does it mean to invent counter-conducts that do not in turn become programs?
What would it mean to practice a theology that refuses to become the instrument of what it critiques—a theology capable of unveiling the corruption of the good without succumbing to the temptation to administer it?
How might one speak from the margins without erecting the margins into a new authority?
And what if the deepest corruptions are precisely those we no longer dare to name?
What if theology must once again become a place of lucidity—not to correct, but to allow what still trembles to come forth?

The purpose of this colloquium is not to add one more discourse to existing discourses, nor to establish yet another critique of modernity, nor to rehabilitate any particular institution. We gather to examine Ivan Illich’s method in order to learn to see together what is at stake in the folds of language, in everyday gestures, in the dispositifs that organise our practices, and within institutions themselves.
His method is not a framework to be applied but a form of 
discernment, requiring a shared and convivial labour for determining what remains alive within the inheritances we bear, and for naming what must be questioned, shifted, or released.

——

Dec 5, 2025, from David: Thanks for your letter, and the prospectus for the conference.  

          In The Rivers North of the Future, Ivan persistently referred to what he was saying as a hypothesis.  He also insisted throughout the second half of his career that he was preeminently a historian, and "no theologian." ("I am no theologian, [and] no one can tell me that I am." p. 121). It's puzzling therefore to find your prospectus beginning with the claim that Illich offers a theological method rather than "a hypothesis derived from historical exercises."  I think I understand what you are getting at - he offers a stance, not a system - but your claim does seem, at first glance, to contradict the words of the man you're interpreting.

 Dec 11, 2025, from Anna: thank you for your comment! You are absolutely right, I agree with you, I believe we should go over these formulations before the final draft of the description. Thank you for offering your view. It is important to be conscientious in these matters. This document was co-written, so I will have to discuss with the others, of course. As for myself, I've taken a deep impression by your words on p. 9 in your book, where you describe the feeling of being called to answer, to offer your own power of interpretation in probing the depth and meaning of these dense reflections that he chose to disclose to you: ”What I had asked for asked something of me in turn. A hypothesis needs testing: research themes need to be followed up. ... With this book I offer my answer.” The way I understand my own work, is exactly like this. I come from a different generation, a different tradition, and I did not know the man, only his texts, but I would like to creatively respond to and think with this hypothesis from my point of view, find resonances in surprising places. I regard my own work as quite constructive, but therefore I also see the importance of being very clear about this constructive element, of not putting words or perspectives in the mouth of Illich, if it is really my own reaction and interpretation. So thank you. 

I will keep you informed regarding the progress of our planning.

——

Dec 15, 2025, from David: Thanks for yours.  I recently received the new issue of Conspiratio.  Reading my friend Simon Ravenscroft's piece, I thought it might be germane to what you and your colleagues are saying in your prospectus for your conference, so I thought I'd send it along.

——

Feb 24, 2026, from Anna: thank you for bringing my attention to the new issue of Conspiratio, it looks very interesting! I look forward to dive into it and read it more carefully – the whole issue, and especially the text by Ravenscroft that you mention. The last months have been particularly intense for me, but I hope to have more time for reading and reflecting in the coming months.

——

March 12, 2026, from Anna: […] Many of the invited participants are academic theologians, of different denominational backgrounds, but mainly Catholic. I very much appreciate your latest book on Illich, and you might depart from that if you like. But you are free to choose what you would like to highlight in this context! As you see, the title suggests that we would like to explore the theological vein in the thought of Ivan Illich, while also respecting his stated position (I am no theologian).

——

May 14, 2026: CORRUPTIO OPTIMI QUAE EST PESSIMA conference, Rome

——
Jun 2, 2026, from Anna: thank you once again for your beautiful presentation in Rome a few weeks ago! I was so happy to see you, and to talk to you, even if it was on the screen!

There were, as it turned out, several convergences between our two talks. I also addressed the theme of the Kingdom, and in some cases we quoted the same passages from Illich, although of course from somewhat different perspectives. I wanted to explore if it could prove productive to use the concept of ”play”, as its is so brilliantly interpreted by Johann Huizinga in his famous book Homo ludens from 1938, in order to analyze what I find to be a strong undercurrent in Illich's understanding of faith and the Kingdom – the emphasis on the festive dimension of community, on the jocose, on laughter and on friendship as a celebrative mode of being.

I now, even more strongly, wish to explore this path. My intention is to do this with more precision, but also by taking a stronger stance in the article that is planned to result from this talk (the idea is only roughly sketched in the talk). I asked the audience if they knew of texts or talks by Illich where he comments on the notion of play, and Fabio mentioned the text ”The Meaning of Cuernavaca” in the Jesuit Mission, April 1967. I see that you also quote this text in your talk, in note 37. I know he also mentions play in ”Concerning Aesthetic and Religious Experience”, but otherwise I have not found passages or texts where Illich himself analyzes ”play”.

Nevertheless, I believe this to be a fruitful cross-fertlization. I would like to ask you two things: do you happen to have a digital version of ”The Meaning of Cuernavaca” that you would be willing to send to me? And do you know of other texts by Illich that could be pertinent for this theme? And, of course, I am also very much open for potential criticisms of this idea, if you have any.

I send you my talk, if you would like to take a look at it (but please feel free not to do so, needless to say!). I hope I do not claim too much of your time if I give you a brief outline of my line of thought also in this email – please forgive me if I am being presumtious! I would be most grateful for any indications as to which texts I might turn to by Illich, and no one knows his work better than you do. Here goes: I do see striking similarities between Illich's understanding of a lived faith and the notion of play, with due respect of important differences of course. What interests me is that Illich makes us aware that the ethical grasp of the social reality is very easily perverted. Play, on the other hand, is singled out by the fact that it cannot be domesticated, that it is lived – and relational! – freedom, that it cannot be subsumed under purposiveness, that it can only be understood as an answer to a call, and that it, in this sense, is immune to the kind of institutional perversion that has resulted from an ethical perspective of the I-Thou-relationship. Huizinga helps us see that play in not an isolated actvity, but comes from an attitude to reality closely related to religion. Play, in its true essence, is a gift that cannot be instrumentalised, without ceasing to exist (I am saying this well aware of the vast industries surronding play in our societies – yet even within these frameworks, it holds true I believe. The over-payed soccer players, the gamers or artists, can never be or stay masters of their trade if they loose thier capacity to play, to have fun, to heed the call to play).

——

Jun 3, 2026, from David: Thanks for yours. I'm happy to hear that we're on the same track. I'll read your paper and send you The Meaning of Cuernavaca as soon as I can.

——

Jun 7, 2026, from David: I'm about to write to you, but, when I began by attaching the pages of The Meaning of Cuernavaca, I was told that that the file size exceeded my email capacity, and they would have to be sent to you via Google Drive, so I'm doing that first. I have no idea why so short a short text would make so big a file. This is the form in which Fabio Milana sent them to me, when he discovered this interesting little piece years ago. I'll continue in a separate letter.

——

The Meaning of Cuernavaca

——

June 7, 2026, from David: I've read your talk and rejoiced in it. I'm so glad you're thinking along these lines. I think you've understood Ivan very well - about folly and ethics and many other things. You've certainly understood him as I do, and I think you've also begun, with appropriate delicacy and discretion, to tease out the implications of what he says. Particularly important to me in what you wrote was the following paragraph:

The idea’s centre of gravity is generated by a process that can be likened to the splitting of the atom. The tension between the two incommensurable interpretations, is an effect of a fundamental rupture within this idea itself, and it has given rise to a reality where the mystery of evil and salvation have become inseparable. Illich understands the Samaritan’s action as a response to a call, so it appears that what we are dealing with, in this split, is the corruption of the truth-form of the call, and its transformation into the kind of externalized, scientific truth I referred to above: truth as the outcome of the successful establishment of universally valid, and empirically validated, rules.

Your daring to speak here of "a reality in which the mystery of evil and salvation have become inseparable" gave me courage. If you can find time to read the attached essay you will see why. I wrote it with some trepidation because I am at the limits of my understanding and my vocabulary in what I say in this piece. And also because Ivan said so much, and yet so little, in the interviews that comprise Rivers that I want to be clear on where he stops and I start. I believe Sajay Samuel intends to publish it soon in a special issue of Conspiratio, a journal I'm assuming you're familiar with (https://thinkingwithivanillich.net/conspiratio/)

It's been many years since I've read Homo Ludens, but I've remembered it as well as any book I've ever read, and I think reading Illich and Huizinga together is a very promising idea. As far as sources in Illich go, I'm sorry to say that Illich, so far as I know, never really develops the idea of play in his work, though it may be that "The Meaning of Cuernavaca" will be of some help. In general I'd say that the early writings - The Powerless Church, Celebration of Awareness, and The Church, Change and Development - are your best source. The last one may be hard to find, but I just discovered that an indispensable Illich archivist called David Tinapple has made a PDF of it available. The long piece called Mission and Midwifery may be helpful. Another find of Fabio's, which might be worth a look, if you haven't seen it, is on my website.. And finally there's Ivan's last talk in Lucca in the fall of 2002 which Sajay reprinted in Conspiratio

I've posted my talk for the Rome conference on my website in case you, or any of the other participants, want to refer to it.

Nils Christie

Dec 29, 2013, from Nils: Subject: Friends of Ivan. Dear friends of Ivan, and of Hedda and me. I have been working with questions of development recently, its dubious benefits. And then of course, Ivan appears in my thoughts. And with him you all; Barbara, Silja and Matthias, and further off to Feodor in East and Jutta and David in the West. I have so many good memories from rich encounters we have had.

But why work on development?

Because of overdevelopment. This little society has been severely hit by affluence. It has not been good for us that we found oil. We are tempted to believe we can manage our lives independent of other human beings. We have a political party here named “Fremskrittspartiet”, – the Progress Party. I argue for an alternative party. I call my party “Tilbakeskrittspartiet.” The party for stepping backwards.

I fear we are losing one of our most important fortunes; the trust in other people. On international studies, we are generally rated as being at the top in trusting others (naiveté it is also called). But independence creates distance to others. Distance is an enemy of trust. We will need “experts” to compensate. When neighbourhoods, kept together by close associations between those that live there, become anomic, experts on social control take over.

But we are of course envied by most of the world. One consequence of our wealth is an extreme influx of foreigners. Immigrants are a blessing, – but as a river, not a flood. Is it in this situation possible to preserve a national identity? I happen to like that identity, – it was this one that made our welfare state possible. I do also think it is easier to raise defences against the wild forms of capitalism from small, easily over-viewed systems than from the large systems so difficult to see and understand.

* * *

As to other aspects of life: Hedda is in a full job as a professor of Criminology. I have of course been pensioned since long. I hate the title of “emeritus”, who knows if I am, but enjoy not being responsible for teaching, and especially not to examine students, and instead having time for writing and participating in the public debate.

Some health problems are inevitable at my age. A leg would not follow my commands some months ago, and forced me on crutches. But two or three weeks ago I could tear them away, and now I am back on the bike! And what a bike! An electric one! The pedals are there for use, but if needed, a little engine to one of the wheels give me the extra push I need. Other bikers will often not observe the little engine, and I have to tell them that I cheat, this to prevent their depression when the old man passes them uphill.

The catastrophic development of the heating of the globe has kept snow completely away from Oslo. It is as in Italy. We were there some weeks ago, invited by Beppe Grillo, the “clown” (they call him so) who attempts to change Italy. He got 25 % of all votes at last election. He had read one of my books, just translated to Italian (A suitable amount of crime) and wanted me to participate. I could not resist. The greatest audience I have ever had, 100,000 at the place of victory, build by Mussolini. He was to receive the applause from here, if he had not been hanged. But now it was Beppe and Dario Fo and me and some I have forgotten. We all talked from a huge platform. It was a great experience. I attach what I said, and some other speeches, if I find them.

Then one more thing: Thanks for all good encounters I have had with and from you all…—

Jan 13, 2014, from David: How good to receive the letter you sent just after Christmas. I enjoyed both papers you attached, especially the longer one, Beyond the Obvious, where you had a little more chance to develop your argument. The Beppe Grillo event sounds quite remarkable. I had only a superficial Canadian newspaper level knowledge of his movement, when we got your letter, so we looked him up, but even from more extensive sources on-line, I'm still not sure I've completely grasped its nature. Perhaps it's somewhat ambiguous, as so many populist phenomena are. I'm sure, at least, that his followers can only have benefited from your counsel.

I don't know if it will reassure you at all, but winter has been pretty old-fashioned in Toronto this year: snow, a fairly damaging ice-storm around Christmas time which left many people without electricity, as falling branches knocked out power lines, and extreme cold in early January. Now a thaw has hit, but the city still somewhat resembles a skating rink.

Silya Samerski wrote just the other day and suggested that she, or I should be interviewing what she called witnesses to Ivan's life and time - she mentioned particularly you, Theodor and Majid. I think this is a good idea, and, with the approval of the witnesses, I may try to do it - with Silya or by myself - when I'm next in Europe. Sajay and Samar, when I last spoke to them, were planning to convene a gathering of friends in northern Italy in late June. Perhaps we could entice you and the other elders there.

My hopes for the year just beginning involve my getting to grips with this book about Ivan's life and thought that I have been talking about, working up to, and walking around. The first year of retirement allowed me a wonderful freedom to explore many of the paths that CBC-work had been kept me from following. Now it's time to begin stalking Ivan in a much more focused way.

Apr 18, 2014, from Nils: Fine that you phoned. I had not opened the mail for some days, struggling with a resistant article. I think the system for what in English literature is called "restorative justice" is endangered by its success. Many want to use these boards in the service of the penal system. It will kill the system. I attach the manuscript, finished yesterday. Now I am back to life and repeat what Hedda certainly said; some changes in the dates for your arrival does not matter at all! But tell us, when you know, so that the table will be set, for talks and other pleasures!

Marcus Rempel

Apr 28, 2016, from Marcus: While we are growing in familiarity...this "Beatitude for Bucket-Poopers" feels ready to share.

Apr 30, 2016, from David: I'm delighted with your beatitude.  Thank you.  As well as being nicely written, and well argued, it came close to me in several ways.  One was that I had just been writing about Shadow Work myself, and had quoted several of the passages that you also note.   Another was dismay at the recent stories from Attawapiskat, and at the widespread assumption that what such a community needs is more grief counsellors,   And then there was the complaining after the last federal budget allocated only half a billion dollars for housing, without anyone seemingly even thinking to ask what prevents "unemployed" people from building their own houses.  All of this you were able to write about, at least implicitly, with sympathetic tact.  I found it very encouraging that you could and would do so.

May 11, 2016, from Marcus: I am sending a few more pieces of my manuscript: the prologue and introduction, as well as a chapter entitled: Sex Fiends: Jian Ghomeshi, My Rooster and Me. I am curious what you will make of my analysis of the scandal surrounding your former fellow employee at the CBC. 

On a side note: what is your rule for capitalizing the words Gospel, Cross and Church? My editor uses a fairly strict rule of only capitalizing when these are part of proper names or titles. I see other writers capitalizing these also when they refer to "the big idea" for which these words stand. Is this a Catholic/Protestant divergence in spelling practice?  

I grew up speaking & writing German, which capitalizes all nouns, so I tend to capitalize rather enthusiastically. Can you help me settle this difference with my editor?

 May 12, 2016, from David: Thanks for these new sections of your book.  I hope to begin reading them soon, as I said in my last note.  I tend to capitalize weighty terms myself, so I'm with you rather than your editor.  Certainly all the terms you mention I would capitalize.  I don't think  it's a Catholic/Protestant difference, unless Anglicans like me  count as closet Catholics.  I think English never followed the German practice entirely, but, if you take down a volume of Blake or Coleridge, a lot of nouns are capitalized for emphasis. 

May 13, 2016, from Marcus: Thanks David for the boost to my predilection for emphatic capitalization.

 I am attaching more chapters as they are completed, not assuming your reading to keep pace with my sending. I am putting in a final push to get this project off my desk before the growing season swallows me whole. Having a chapter polished up enough to feel good about sending it to you feels like as good a marker as any to consider it "finished."

 I began listening today to "Beyond Institutions" on your website. Ten minutes into the program I had to interrupt the podcast to excitedly phone my friend Laurie, my collaborator in the inclusion of folks with mental disabilities in the work of our farm, described in "The Soil of Friendship." So many resonances.

Oct. 6, 2016, from Marcus: This just in from Mark MacDonald, National Indigenous Bishop for the Anglican Church of Canada.   

"This is an attempt to speak to a new world, a world that many churches appear to have no capacity to recognize.  Using the works of Girard and Illich as a framework, a new basis for faith and action emerges.  The very personal and revealing way you demonstrate their thought is very useful.  Although I might not follow you there, I found my own imagination animated and my thoughts illumined.  I am happy for reading it and, as a believer in militant nonviolence, will think about your conclusions for some time."

October 5, 2016, forward from Marcus: As my computer likes to say, aw, snap! This just in from Mike Leaches of Orbis Books, a progressive Catholic publishing house in New York. 

 Subject: Re: One more commendation

“I am so sorry, Marcus, but it is no go. Everyone saw its merits. The publisher thought it was one of the best written unsolicited manuscripts to come along in some time. But to quote Clint Eastwood who said to Gene Hackman before blowing his brains out in Unforgiven, "Deservin's got nothin' to do with it." Or in this case, "Quality's got nothin to do with it."

It is extremely difficult for a small religion book publishing house to stay in business these days and Orbis is no exception. It just cannot sell enough copies of a book, however good, on Girard and Illich, however influential, with long Canadian examples, however pertinent, to come close to breaking even. Orbis has published a ton of books over the years that lost money and gotten away with it. That time is not now. I am sorry.

The suggestion that emerged is for you to try and publish it with a Canadian publisher. The sales manager suggested Wood Lake Publishing in BC, or Copper House. That failing, there is the route so many authors are taking these days, including previously published and successful authors, and that is self-publishing.

I wish you success, and peace and joy in all you do. Thank you for sharing this wonderful work with me.

Mike”

Oct 7, 2016, response to Mike from Marcus, copied to David: Dear Mike, thanks for what one of my friends is calling "the most encouraging rejection I have ever seen." It was not too hard to take. 

 A musician friend of mine was musing about how two or three decades ago, there were 30 bars in Winnipeg where he and his mates could get regular gigs. Today there is only a small handful. People are still consuming music, but not live and local. They go to the touring mega-concerts, or they go online. My friend was decrying the parallel fate of the modest local church, disappearing as the masses go to the megachurches, or simply dissipate and wander off alone. It seems that the small religious publishing house is feeling a similar squeeze. "Never have so many people written so many words for so few readers," I heard Margaret Atwood say recently. "The math does not compute." And yet the math has to be done, and the beans have to be counted. Thanks ever so much for entertaining my pitch as seriously as you did. If nothing else, your affirmation, along with that of Alison and Cayley and others, has given me the confidence to hang out my shingle and attempt to gather a new worshipping community in the old, nearly defunct Anglican sanctuary I mention in "The Shape of the Body." I can't afford seminary, but I was afforded the time to read and write and reflect the past two winters, and I have taken your affirmation and that of other respected elders to be as close as this ecumenical love-child may come to being credentialed by any particular denominational tradition.

 Oct.6, 2016, from Marcus: THANK YOU to James Alison, for opening this particular door. I remain amazed that Orbis even looked at me. And thanks and hugs to all of you for blessing and encouraging me on my way! I remain confident that my book will land with a publisher somewhere, if somewhere smaller and more local. For the sake of the thoughts I want to share widely, this is disappointing, but for the sake of my own sanity and the congruity of my life, I trust that small really is beautiful and that locality is the soil of friendship. 

 From Marcus to David: from the Introduction to his book 

My pacifist Mennonite parents tell me they named me for the Gospel writer Mark. Now, the Mennonites threw out some beautiful babies (art, liturgy, memory of the saints) with the high church bath water during the radical Reformation, but one thing they got right was that any serious reading of Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount leads to a refusal of war. While I never had a natural disposition for loving my enemies, it was never hard for me to see that any Christian justification of war was sheer nonsense.The rest of my name comes from having a father named Peter Rempel, along with an uncle and a grandfather named Peter Rempel—both on my mother’s side. Somewhere in my family line, there are probably some non-Mennonites with more original names, but they are too far back for any of us to remember.

I’ve learned that the literal meaning of Marcus is “son of Mars,” the Roman god of war. When I look into my heart, this also feels apt. For like many peace activists, I have often taken the Christian love for the poor and the stranger as convenient grounds to hate the rich and the established—“The Man,” as we like to say.

Jan 2, 2017, from Marcus to David: I thought you might find this book review interesting. This deconstruction of early capitalism dovetails with Illich's critique of development as a war on subsistence.
Two quotes stand out for me:
"The possession of a cow or two, with a hog, and a few geese, naturally exalts the peasant. . . . In sauntering after his cattle, he acquires a habit of indolence. Quarter, half, and occasionally whole days, are imperceptibly lost. Day labour becomes disgusting; the aversion increases by indulgence. And at length the sale of a half-fed calf, or hog, furnishes the means of adding intemperance to idleness." (from an 18th century pro-industrial pamphlet)
“Our Forests and great Commons (make the Poor that are upon them too much like the Indians) being a hindrance to Industry, and are Nurseries of Idleness and Insolence.” (John Bellers)

Back to cutting some firewood out of the bush. My whole day is being imperceptibly lost. Sigh. Wishing you a happy and indolent New Year!

 July 16, 2026, from Marcus to Kate Cayley:

Just One Song

 I love a neighbour who loves Jesus

He's her saviour strong and kind

I love a neighbour who found Buddha

Finally taught her peace of mind

I love a brother who wants nothing

but the plain and solid facts

I love a priest who keeps performing

the sacramental act

 

I love two mamas who have promised

wife and wife until the end

I love a granny in my church 

who rails against this trend

when we all sit down at table

breaking bread and drinking wine

what's one song that we can share

when we aren't of one mind?

 

O give me one song

just one song

that I can sing with all my friends

Give me one song

just one song

where we can let our voices blend

with parts for all the colours

the Living Lovelight sends

 

I love a neighbour with a farm

that's organic as can be

he farms and dreams and writes

for a future poison-free

I love a neighbour who's a good ol' boy

loves to hunt and fish and fly

there he goes in his crop-duster

delivering pesticide

 

I love a neighbour who's preparing

for the end of fossil fuel

I love a neighbour boy with a pick up truck

so big it's monster-cool

It's a strange and straining place

this checkered neighbourhood

everybody made so different

yet somehow all made good

 

O give me one song…

And could it be a Hallelujah, Hallelujah,

A Hallelujah Song?

 I wrote that song in the early years after our move out to this rural neighbourhood, when I could still imagine, somehow, that there could be some table I could tend, some song I could find that could draw these neighbours together. Today, after various attempts at trying to organize different versions of a “community band,” each with their own relational and logistical disappointments, the longing expressed in this song feels naive, foolhardy. Since those early days, a number of polarizations have taken their toll that feel even more impossible to bridge than the ones listed in the song.

Today I host a small house church. I’ve more or less stopped inviting new people. And I’ve given up on, or at least become a lot more distant with the  the neighbours who clearly are never going to come. Which makes me ask myself, was I only friends with them because I was hoping to recruit them to my project? Were these strictly instrumental friendships?

Since David’s death, I’ve been thinking about hosting a monthly potluck/singalong for whoever wants to come, with no agenda other than neighbourliness. We'll see.

 August 13 2026 to Kate Cayley: David introduced me to thinkers who helped me understand the beauty and the necessary instability of a spiritual tradition that heralds the outcast as centre. A tradition that lives in awareness of a debt that it can never pay. A tradition that must face the truth of the victim again and again. A tradition that must sing "I crucified thee" each year before it can sing of Easter graces and glories……I write as a pastor whose children do not go to church….. I feel that I have failed. I love outsiders like Simone Weil, and Ivan Illich, and David Cayley, but I carry an ache in my heart that the identification with outsiders that I helped pass on to my children finally sent them outside my church and my tradition…..I must admit that over the years, I have looked with increasing envy at my more conservative Anabaptist kin, who seem to know better how to pass their tradition on from one generation to the next. I've had some wonderful conversations with Julian Waldner, a young Hutterite who interviewed David at one point. Julian's mix of intellectual openness and groundedness in his people's tradition made a deep impression on me. I suspect that if the Christian faith is still being practiced a hundred or a thousand years from now, it will be more thanks to teachers like Julian than pastors like me.

Outside now to pick tomatoes.

Julian Waldner

Jan 11, 2026, from Julian Waldner: I recently wrote a piece that will be published in a Lutheran journal called Promissio. That piece is my attempt to work out an intuition that there is an interesting (and surprising) congruence between Illich and Luther. One point of congruence is the sense of levity that you get in Illich and (arguably in Luther). Here is how I put it in a paragraph that was cut from my piece: 

...what first attracted me to both Luther and Illich is their humour. The levity that characterizes these thinkers is not accidental, it is the essence of their vision. Both Luther and Illich recognized with G. K. Chesterton that “Joy… is the gigantic secret of the Christian.” Brian Brock describes the theology of Luther as a “decisive break with the tenor and sensibility of the patristic era” by reintroducing into the Christian tradition a “theology of joy and laughter.” Illich described Jesus as an “anarchist saviour” “whose only economics are Jokes.” Illich did not mean this as a dismissal, but as an encapsulation of the “naked saviour” he tried to follow, and as a description of a way of life best summed up in what he called ‘Conviviality’. 

I don't think this is unimportant--humour often points to the heart of things. The laughter in Illich and Luther I think points to something I would call grace. 

The more direct connection I see is with Illich's diagnosis of modernity. The argument is too complex to summarize here, but here are a few flashpoints: 

- I see a connection between Luther's critique of 'works righteousness' which can be described as us trying to 'earn' or create eternal life by our own efforts--and Illich's account of Modernity as a quasi-religion whereby we essentially try ensure that the good life is certain and predictable. 

- Luther sees this quest for 'works righteousness' as tending to undermine itself--I see a parallel here with Illich's notion of 'paradoxical counterproductivity'. 

- Finally, Luther sees the gospel as pure gift, a sense that we have been given freely what we need. In Berry's words "what we need is here." I see this as the essence of Illich's vision: despite modernity's vision of scarcity, Illich believes that what is needed for the good life is here. Like Luther's notion of living by faith, this a contested posture that requires venture to live out. 

Those are some of the high points, there is a lot more to the argument and I hope someone like you will be able to pick out the other threads. I am really curious to hear your comments/feedback/critiques. I do realize that by drawing on Luther I am stepping on some toes--in many accounts of modernity he is often styled as the villain. I see my reading of Luther as an account of an alternative modernity rather than as a return to the premodern.

Jan. 13, 2026, from David: Thanks for your letter, and your essay.  I'm not very deeply versed in Luther, but I found your case, and your comparison to Illich persuasive as well as instructive.  I've just finished a long essay which tries to read Illich and C.G. Jung together and braid heretofore quite separate strands of my formation.  It's long, and I don't want to impose it on you, but, in the final section of the piece, you will find some observations on the part humour plays in Illich's philosophy that may be germane to your reflections.  (p. 34ff.)  If you're interested in the thing as a whole, I would, of course, be delighted.  Glad to be in touch.

https://www.davidcayley.com/blog/2026/8/17/b42vh6v3yy15its7zitld9eb3smdsi

Jan 17, 2026, from Julian: Thank you for your kind words and for sending along this article. I have some comments for you that you will hopefully find helpful. I’ve added some questions in bold. 

I was interested to see your reference to Thiel (6). I’ve wondered what to make of his warnings of the anti-Christ. Do you think his perspective is aligned with Illich, I.e. good intentions gone awry?  

I was intrigued by your description of what Jung thinks has gone wrong with us in modernity: “The radiant Christ will invoke a shadowy Satan; the attempt to be “better than we are” will make us worse that we are; the kingdom of Christ, Christendom, will be succeeded by a Luciferian modernity in which technology and economy are king.” (33) This is well expressed and reminds me both of Illich’s counter-productivity and of my critique via Luther. I thought too that your use of Jung to describe our world as off balance were very apt (16). One additional piece of empirical evidence I would add to this is the misbalance of the genders in our current context. You see this not only politically (Trumpian machismo vs Liberal permissiveness) but also literally in statistics showing that men and women are drifting further and further apart politically. In a poll I saw today, men and women were over 20 points apart, with women becoming ever more liberal, and men ever more conservative.


I was curious about your description of the trinity as off balance compared to symbols with 4. As you are probably aware, here in Canada we are focused on “indigenizing” things and resisting “colonialism” (certainly in part the heritage of Christianity). Part of what this involves is integrating the symbol of the medicine wheel and its 4 directions. I don’t necessarily see this as a sign of societal health, do you? (I’m also curious if you’ve come across the book Meditations of the Tarot, you might find it interesting if you haven’t.) 

I would now like to offer some reasons that I wouldn’t think of Illich as a natural fit with Jung. I am not very familiar with Jung—my only exposure to him comes through that famous contemporary Canadian disciple of his! Maybe that introduction to him has warped my sense of his thought. As I understand Jung (reading your paper confirms it) he understands religion and Christianity primarily as something that sits in the deep background of a civilization or of the psyche. As you put it, Jung is inside Christianity in the sense that “he regarded his culture, his inheritance as deeply and irrevocably Christian.”(9) I see Illich is having a more radical and in a sense “apocalyptic” view of Christianity where it can never be the ‘background’ or ‘civil religion’ of a culture and remain itself, but is always something that stands as a possibility outside or beyond culture or standard morality. (I think of Kierkegaard’s distinction between ‘Christianity’ and ‘Christendom’. Would Illich roughly affirm this?) 

A word on how I think about the category of the ‘Apocalyptic’. There is a strain of New Testament interpretation that emphasizes the ‘apocalyptic’ nature of especially the Pauline letters. This apocalyptic theology sees Christ in the incarnation as breaking into a world ruled by dark powers and opening up the possibility of a new way of being. This Christ-event makes visible the powers that enslave us, while also enabling us to be freed from their rule to participate in the kingdom of God. (See for example a book by Philip Ziegler, Militant Grace: The Apocalyptic Turn and the Future of Christian Theology. Its people in this ‘apocalyptic’ school that I’ve seen draw on Illich, e.g. the work of Brian Brock in Wondrously Wounded) Heady stuff, but notice the difference with Jung. For Jung, as you describe him, because of his Kantian presuppositions, there can be no discontinuity between God and humanity, nothing new can come in from the outside, it is all one seamless garment. In Illich on the other hand, I see this apocalyptic sense: something NEW has happened in the incarnation that changes history. Even in his sociological/critical work you can see him (like Ellul) as describing the powers that hold us captive. In this sense his sociological work is partly theological, he “could not have known with my unaided eyes and mind” (1) 

Like the theologian you reference in your article (27) the notion of there being evil in God is a stumbling block for me too. But here again, I wonder if the notion of evil as privation isn’t a better fit for Illich then a Jungian notion of the repressed shadow. He says that the Incarnation makes possible the anti-Christ; I wonder if this can be read as analogous to how in the Augustinian tradition of privatio boni evil is made possible by Creatio ex nihalo. The Christian doctrine that God makes the world out of nothing, opens up the possibility of creation returning to that nothingness rather than choosing to continue to abide in existence. Similarly for Illich, the possibility of the incarnation opens up the possibility that this can be perverted along worldly lines: seeking to secure what can only come as a gift. 

Feb 6, 2026, from David to Julian:  I'm sorry to be so slow responding to your comments on my Jung essay.  I began a response, then got sidetracked, and just remembered that I never completed it, or sent the letter.  You'll pardon an old man, I hope.

Thiel is a puzzling figure, but I don't think his perspective is in any way aligned with Illich's.   As far as I can make out, Thiel sees the anti-Christ as a brake on innovation and technological progress.  He was recently in Innsbruck for a conversation with theologian Wolfgang Palaver, and I found the report on this event in the Bulletin of the Colloquium on Violence and Religion interesting: https://violenceandreligion.com/bulletin-86-november-2025/#President.

      You write:  I was curious about your description of the trinity as off balance compared to symbols with 4. As you are probably aware, here in Canada we are focused on “indigenizing” things and resisting “colonialism” (certainly in part the heritage of Christianity). Part of what this involves is integrating the symbol of the medicine wheel and its 4 directions. I don’t necessarily see this as a sign of societal health, do you? (I’m also curious if you’ve come across the book Meditations of the Tarot, you might find it interesting if you haven’t.)   

My answer:  There are two questions here - one is Jung's contrast between an allegedly unstable and incomplete trinity and a more grounded quadernity; the second is the huge question of indigeneity.  On the first I would say I am interested in Jung's claims, and provoked by them, without feeling that I can reach a judgment on how the divine is to be imagined.  (The first big series I did for Ideas, back at the beginning of the 1980's was called "Between Two Ages" - that is still how I imagine our contemporary situation - a situation that I think calls us to "live in the question," as I said in my book about the CBC, rather than rushing to premature on matters for which we as yet lack language - the centuries that elapsed between the life and death of Jesus and the completion of the edifice of Christian dogma might be a rough analogy.)  On the indigenous question, I think Jung's proposal is partly a call for a restoration of "primitive" elements that tend to get lost in the Christian era. . …….This is a huge subject, and one on which the price of speaking out is now set very high - witness the strange case of Francis Widdowson - fired from her university post, shouted down and arrested at other universities, and treated as an exponent of the "far right" for putting forward what was once a conventionally Marxist analysis of how the indigenous industry functions as a comprador elite which actually perpetuates the immiseration of its own people.  This is definitely not in the direction of what you call "societal health."  (About the Tarot book - I learned of it recently - borrowed it from the library - read enough to make me want to read more but haven't followed up as yet - what about you?)

        About Jung you say that he is only a "cultural Christian" who treats Christianity as a "background" or "civil" religion, and that this distinguishes him from the more apocalyptic Illich.   Jung  does say that Christianity is an inescapable inheritance, but I think a careful reading of Answer to Job shows it as the record of a real struggle with God, and the cause of a real wound, like Jacob's dislocated hip. 

        I see Jung, as I wrote, as a pilgrim soul, who changed throughout life, and who used inherited languages that often conflicted with each other.  So, yes, he was decisively influenced by Kant, but whether this means that he consistently held that, in your words, "there can be no discontinuity between God and humanity, [and] nothing new can come in from the outside" seems questionable to me.  A lot turns on what "outside" means in our present world.  Jung stretched the term unconscious until it finally comprehended the entire realm of spirit.  This "unconscious" produces novelty - the Incarnation is something new from Jung's perspective too.   Perhaps it is an outside that is inside. 

     Thanks for your excerpt from David Noble.  I read that book a long time ago, and remember comparing it unfavourably with Illich's account, but perhaps I didn't do it full justice. 

      Well, these are deep waters, Julian, and I'm grateful that you're willing to venture into them with me.  To be continued, I hope. 

Dara Malloy

From Jutta, Sept.15, 2026: Dear Dara, I came across this obituary for Ivan by you  https://www.aislingmagazine.com/aislingmagazine/articles/TAM31/IvanIllichobituary.html. Could I reproduce it on David's website, under your name? I can also just link it, but so many older documents disappear, and I think this one is a keeper. 

From Dara, Sept.16, 2026: Hello Jutta, I heard of David's death almost as soon as it happened, and we too are grieving his loss….. David's contribution was immense on many fronts, but for me he brought us into the mind and thoughts of Ivan in a way that nobody else could or did. I have spent my life trying to get to the bottom of Ivan's insights and feel I still have a long way to go. All of David's books are to hand on my bookshelf and he also had been sending me all his podcasts. He never did get to visit us here and I am sad about that.   

You may know that Ivan would have been 100 on September 4th this year. To mark the occasion, there will be a public gathering in Galway city, Ireland, on October 31st. It will be interesting to see who turns up. I am in touch with quite a few 'next generation' Illich followers who were too young to ever meet Illich or know him personally. 

Yes, of course, you have my permission to put the obituary on David's website.

——

From https://www.aislingmagazine.com/aislingmagazine/articles/TAM31/IvanIllichobituary.html by Dara Malloy. Reprinted by permission.

On the day that Ivan Illich died, Monday December 2nd, 2002, I was eating my dinner in the evening when a phone call came for me. The speaker introduced himself as a South American lawyer who was phoning from Shannon airport after spending a week in Ireland. He told me that he had spent 3 weeks with Ivan Illich in Bremen prior to his visit to Ireland and during that time that Ivan had spoken about us on Aran and insisted that he visit us or at least make contact. Having failed to visit, he was now making contact and communicating warm wishes from Ivan.
It turned out that these warm wishes from Ivan came four hours after his death, when his body was already cold.
At that time of the evening, I still did not know that Ivan was dead. Later that same evening I had an intuition to phone Lee Hoinacki, a close friend and co-worker of Ivan’s, who was living in Philadelphia. I had not spoken to him for a full year, in fact since I had visited him and Ivan a year previous in Bremen. My purpose was to find out how Lee was, not thinking at all of Ivan. But of course the first words out of Lee’s mouth were: “Have you heard the news?”. With that he told me that Ivan had died earlier that day.
Ivan had close friends living all over the world. It was highly unlikely that I was going to be told of his death in time for me to make the funeral. My phone call to Lee was a graced moment. Getting the news on Monday night gave me the time to book my flight to Germany on Tuesday, travel on Wednesday, and be on time for the 9.15 funeral Mass on Thursday morning in Bremen.
I first came across Ivan Illich while I was attending University College Dublin in the early 70s. His book Deschooling Society made a deep and instant impression on me. I responded to reading the book by writing a paper on the subject and circulating it among my friends in college. So began my journey of opposition to the educational system. I spent six years teaching, trying to change it from the inside. Then in 1983, I began to make public protests against the education system. Twenty years later, my wife and I have three small children, and we intend to keep them away from established schooling.
It never struck me in those early days that I would one day meet Ivan Illich, become friends with him, bring him to Ireland on a number of occasions and eventually have him as a godfather to one of my children. But that is what happened, something for which I feel eternally grateful, a grace and privilege that was bestowed upon me and for which I would not have dreamt of asking.

Ivan’s death on December 2nd came as a shock but not as a surprise. Those close to him knew for a number of years that he was dying. The cancerous growth on the right side of his face left him in tremendous pain, for which he would not take any standard medication. On the appearance of the cancer in the mid-seventies, medical experts who were friends of his predicted that he would not live five years longer unless he had surgery. But Ivan, who published his book Medical Nemesis in 1976 (a book which condemned the medical system as one which made you sick) was not prepared to subject himself to the disempowerment the surgery would cause him, and so ignored medical advice. His decision meant that, despite the pain, he was able to continue working right up to his death.
At the age of 76 Ivan had slowed down a lot. Nonetheless, he was still hosting conversations among students and intellectuals in his home, still receiving a regular stream of visitors from across the globe, and still offering a series of lectures at Bremen university during the winter semester.
Ivan died while taking a siesta after his lunch. There was no struggle and no indication beforehand that his death was imminent. In one of his papers he had written of Posthumous Longevity - the modern phenomenon of people being kept alive by the medical system beyond the natural moment of their death. Ivan kept a rosary beads at all times in his pocket and had changed the wording of the Hail Mary to: “...pray for us sinners now and that we may not miss the hour of our death”. Thankfully his prayer was answered in his own case. His body remained on the couch where he had died for three days while those who knew and loved him came and said their farewells. No surgical knife came near him to “establish the cause of death” something which, in the context of his life and what he stood for, would have been a desecration of his body.
In November 2001 I had visited Ivan in Bremen, Germany, for a few days, knowing that it would probably be the last time I would see him. He greeted me with his usual warmth and I basked in the hospitality of his and Barbara Duden’s home. I attended one of his formal conversations with his co-workers and students before I left. Nonetheless it was clear that he was in dreadful pain and that this was sapping his energy and his concentration. As I left, I hoped that I would be able to attend his funeral but I knew that the reality was his death could take place in any of a number of places: Mexico, California, Pennsylvania or Germany. In recent times, he had spent part of every year in these places.
The following year, back home in Aran in August 2002, I had chosen a good dry day to go to a field in Kilmurvey to harvest the rye. We stacked the rye on the trailer of our tractor, all the workers climbed on top, including the children, and we made our way home in the late afternoon. While rounding the bend at Kilmurvey beach, we were signalled by a passing mini-bus to pull over. Not knowing what was going on, I stopped the tractor and walked over to the minibus driver. He told me that one of his passengers wanted to speak to me. In the bus was Daniel Berrigan, on one of his regular visits to Ireland and Aran. We had met on a few previous occasions due to an introduction from an Irish priest friend of his, Pat O’Brien. On this occasion, time was short as we were blocking traffic and these passengers were on their way to catch the ferry. Nonetheless, in the few minutes we had to us, Daniel told me that Ivan had been close to death during the summer and was not sure how well he had recovered.

That evening I phoned Bremen. Ivan was not there but I was told he would be arriving within the week. I was told that he had recovered fully from an infection, which did indeed nearly kill him, and that he was back to himself. That event had taken place in Florence.
I subsequently wrote to Ivan enquiring after his health and recounting my meeting with Daniel Berrigan. A reply to this letter came exactly a week before his death. I later discovered that during this week he had been frantically writing letters to all and sundry. It may be that he had some intuition of his impending death.
Ivan is buried in a Protestant graveyard (there are no Roman Catholic cemeteries in Bremen) at Friedhof Oberneuland, Hohenkampsweg, 28355 Bremen. The grave is unusual in that it is the only grave in the graveyard facing east. It is to be found by walking up the centre path at the back of the church and turning left at the first junction. The grave is then immediately on the left. I am sure that this grave will become a place of pilgrimage, especially as Ivan’s life and writings become more appreciated and understood. I intend to bring my family there some day.
My first direct contact with Ivan was in 1988. I was organising a conference on Alternatives in Education, to be held at Clonard, County Meath, at the site of one of the greatest Celtic monastic schools of the early Christian period. The conference was to coincide with the sitting of the Leaving and Inter Certificate school examinations in June. I needed a high-profile speaker to open the event, and so I wrote to Paulo Freire in Brazil, Fernando Cardenal in Nicaragua, and Ivan Illich in the U.S., hoping for one of them to respond positively. Ivan was the only one to reply. He said he would come, but he told me the title of the conference should be changed to: Alternatives TO Education.
However, a week or so before the event, I phoned Ivan to confirm that all the arrangements were in order. He then told me that there was no way he could leave the bedside of his close friend Erich Fromm who was dying. And so the conference went ahead without him, and my hopes of meeting this famous and inspirational man faded.
Sometime the following year, I came home to find a message waiting for me. I was to phone a person called Ivan at the given number. This was very strange to me. I phoned the number in the U.S. and found myself speaking to Ivan Illich. He said he wanted to apologise for letting me down the previous summer, and wanted to make himself available to me this year instead as a way of recompense.
I could not believe what I was hearing. I have to admit, my first reaction was; the conference is over, it is a bit late now! But on reflection, I realised that any opportunity to meet the man and spend time with him was going to be a bonus, so I accepted his offer and we began to arrange his visit to Ireland.
At the height of his fame in the 70’s, Ivan Illich had visited Ireland and lectured in Dublin to packed attendances. It was early 1974. I had not encountered him at this time, living as I did a secluded life in a Dublin seminary, cut off from the world. However, in the late 80’s, his name had faded off the headlines and only those really interested in his work kept in touch with his flow of ideas.
Ivan said to me that he did not want to give a lecture tour, but preferred if I would bring him around to meet small groups of people throughout the country doing interesting things. In order to cover the costs of his visit, he was willing to give one public lecture, for which we could charge an admission. We needed to make enough money at this lecture to pay for his travel and all the other expenses. He did not want payment of a fee, but requested that I acquire for him some homespun material that he could have made into a suit.
And so the adventure began. He arrived towards the end of May 1989 and stayed in Ireland for three nights. On his arrival, I presented him with our itinerary which included a public lecture at Trinity College, a meeting with the justice office of the Conference of Major Religious Superiors of Ireland (now CORI), a visit to Corofin, Co. Clare, and a visit to Inis Mór. Included were the filming of a television programme to be made by Kairos at Maynooth, and the recording of a radio programme by John Quinn of RTE at Corofin.
Here we hit the first major snag. Ivan told me he had not appeared before television cameras for twenty years and could not bring himself to do so now. I had to phone Kairos in Maynooth and cancel the whole thing, with great personal embarrassment and a lot of people put out. With the proposed radio programme, there was also a problem, but in the end he agreed to go ahead with it provided the recording of the programme was merely as a fly-on-the-wall, without any direct interviewing of him. More about this anon.
The first evening was a lecture in the largest theatre at Trinity College, Dublin. This lecture was organised by the Curriculum Development Unit of TCD who had been very keen to get involved with his visit. It was a great success in the sense that we got a full house and made enough money on the door to cover all the expenses of the trip.
The lecture itself was a bit rambling, given roughly on the theme of “corruptio optimi quae est pessima” (the corruption of the best is the worst), a topic which has been a constant theme of Ivan’s life. He directs his criticism particularly at Christianity. His point is that institutions which grow beyond a certain size end up doing the opposite of what they were set up to do. So, for example, schooling becomes the first obstacle to learning, the medical system requires people to be sick, and the transport system has people stuck for hours in traffic jams. In the case of the caring and healing professions, the gospel injunction to love one’s neighbour has been corrupted so that hospitality, which is to do with friendship and an I-Thou relationship, has been institutionalised to become hospitals, hospices and hostels where the true meaning of hospitality is no longer practiced.
The following morning we had a working breakfast at the house of Joe Dunne, a lecturer in St Patrick’s College, Drumcondra, where we were joined by Sean Healy and Brigid Reynolds from the CMRS Justice Office. Then, it was just a short hop down to the Milltown Institute of Philosophy and Theology where we met with a select group of religious sisters, priests and brothers. Ivan claimed it was the first time he had addressed such a church gathering since he had resigned from the priesthood in the 1970’s, due to a promise he had made to himself at that time.
In the afternoon, we made our way by train to Galway where we were whisked away by car to a place known as The Shed outside Corofin in County Clare. This was the location of an experiment in alternative living where a group of people had set themselves up as a co-operative and were determined to create employment in the area and stem emigration. As part of their project, they had built a community centre which included a work place, a shop, a school for their children, and a community dining area. Other elements of their project were; shared ownership of cars, community house building, and their own banking system. They created employment for themselves in turf and slate production, organic vegetables, window making, house building and the teaching of English to foreign students.
When we arrived at The Shed, we were sat down to a meal, served by the children of the co-operative, so that the adults could participate in a conversation around the table. After dinner, everybody gathered with Ivan in one of the school rooms and he was asked some pre-prepared questions. Then it was off down to the Corofin village hall for a public meeting. As we drove through the main street of Corofin, a village of a few thousand people at most, a large white banner spanned the street with the words emblazoned on it: COROFIN WELCOMES IVAN ILLICH. It was one of my most memorable moments of the trip.
The meeting at the village hall was a meeting that most people who attended it will never forget. It was chaired by Tom Collins, at that time a lecturer in Community Development at St Patrick’s College, Maynooth. When we arrived, the hall was packed to the doors. People had travelled from all over the west and midlands of Ireland to meet and hear this great man. The stage was decked with an array of microphones, and RTE’s John Quinn had set himself up with his tape recorder close to the stage to be the fly-on-the-wall for his radio programme. Ivan was presented with a gift of flowers by some local children, who then appeared on stage to give a performance of Irish dancing and singing.

The whole scene had completely the wrong effect on Ivan, so that by the time he got his turn to address the crowd he was in a rage. He told the assembled audience that he would not speak to them through a microphone, because he would not have any technology get in the way of his face to face encounter with them. He criticised the adults who had organised the singing and dancing of the children, accusing them of turning something at the heart of their culture into a package for the entertainment of tourists and visitors. And finally he said he would not speak from the stage but wanted everybody to turn their seats towards him while he stood in the middle of the hall. This latter was a major logistical nightmare as the hall was completely packed and it meant every single chair had to be moved.

The ensuing discussion was fiery. Quite a number of people from the audience got involved, and Ivan himself, already hot under the collar from the welcoming reception, got even hotter. Tom Collins, the chairman, had an impossible task trying to contain and direct the discussion. It was not what one would call a pleasant evening, unless one could be so detached from the proceedings as to enjoy the cut and thrust of passion-filled arguments and Ivan’s impatience with and intolerance of “fools”. Many people probably went home feeling insulted. On that particular evening, Ivan was all barb and no balm.

As it turned out, the radio crew were delighted. They got enough material on tape to make two half-hour programmes, and John Quinn, who has now just retired, still speaks of the occasion as one of the highlights of his radio career.
The following day was more relaxed and far less hectic. We travelled to Inis Mór, via car and plane, and arrived at my home, a small thatched cottage in the middle of the island, around 11 a.m. The day itself was idyllic, with blue skies and a warm, balmy breeze. It was to be a day of religious ritual rather than discussion and debate.
Ivan met the members of my household. He drank tea, perused the daily paper (something he rarely ever did), and dandled a child on his lap. Then we headed off to the village of Kilronan, a journey of about two miles, on pony and trap courtesy of my neighbour. It was the feast of Corpus Christi and there was to be a Eucharistic procession through the streets of the village. Ivan was ecstatic to discover it and wanted to participate in it to the full. He produced a rosary beads from his pocket, and we joined in the procession, the worship and the singing.
In the afternoon, it being a holy day, we celebrated Mass in Killeany Lodge, where Ivan met more of the extended group who were part of our project on Aran. Ivan called our project an experiment in living and was very supportive of it. I invited him to concelebrate the Mass with me and offered him a stole, but he declined.
By 5 p.m. we had to leave Aran by plane (for which he criticised me ó why could we not have travelled by boat? The answer of course was that time would not permit), in order to catch the last train from Galway to Dublin. Ivan was to take a plane to Germany early the next morning. On the train he relaxed and became very warm towards me, inviting me to come and live with him in Penn State (Pennsylvania State University) in September. I could stay for a month or two and participate in some conversations he was organising, attend his lectures in the college, use the university library, have access to all his writings, and meet many of his friends.
This is exactly what I did; an experience that has been a major watershed in my life. I stayed six weeks with him, in a rented house that was shared by a number of other people, all co-workers of his. The conversations that took place were weekend events with invited participants from all over the world, mainly Europe, the States, and South America. Up to twenty people participated. Each session began with a presentation on some topic and continued with open discussion under the direction of a chairperson. Meals were prepared and eaten communally, where discussion continued informally and people got to know one another.
I felt very privileged to be at these gatherings, and a little out of my depth, as all of these participants were established intellectuals well accustomed to research and intellectual debate and many of whom had published books. Participants included, for example, Wolfgang Sachs (German), Gustavo Esteva (Mexican), David Abram (U.S.), Hans Achterhaus (Holland) and Majid Rahnema (Iran), all of whom are now well-known names in their fields.
I came home from Penn State with a large bundle of Ivan’s writings and lectures (many unpublished), as well as other material. I had written permission from Ivan to publish anything of his in Ireland. From this came the impetus to launch the AISLING Magazine, the first issue of which came out a little over a year later, in January 1991.
Since that time, Ivan has been to Ireland on two further occasions. The first was in 1990 to attend a conversation we organised in Killeany Lodge, Inis Mór, on the subject of education. On that occasion he travelled with Lee Hoinacki and Manfred Verner, two of his co-workers. The conversation was modelled on the conversations I had experienced at Penn State, and in attendance were people we had invited from all over Ireland. It was at this meeting that Ivan first met John Seymour, the well known writer and campaigner on environmental matters. John subsequently went to Germany to work with Ivan and others on a “Statement on Soil”.
The second occasion was a brief visit in November of 1999 to attend the baptism ceremony of our twin daughters, Macha and Surnaí, and to act as godfather to Surnaí. It was to be his first and last time to meet the child. However, I think that Surnaí will be aware of him all through her life.
Ivan was a nomad on this earth. He owned no property, never married or had children, lived with friends, and took on work only where he was invited to do so by friends. He told me he made very little money out of his publications. His contracts with universities were always on the basis that he could lecture on topics he had chosen himself. At lectures that I attended in Penn State, most of those attending were members of staff, there out of interest. He was ruthless with college students who chose his courses simply to get points. He would weed them out on their first day, tell them they had their points and order them not to come back.
From the late 60ís onwards, Ivan’s ideas were foundational for such diverse causes as the green movement, the deschooling/homeschooling movement, basic Christian communities, liberation theology, alternative medicine, appropriate technology, and the survival of indigenous peoples and their cultures.
I have often wondered why I was privileged to be so close to Ivan. He surrounded himself with intellectuals, most of whom worked in universities, or spent their time writing books and lecturing. His work against the institutionalising and technologising of life was always at an intellectual level. Unlike Gandhi, he never took on physical work or walked on the campaign trail. I surmise that the reason he warmed to me and to our project on Aran was that he saw that we too were doing the same work as he, but at a practical level; creating a way of life that was subsistent in itself, true to its cultural tradition, and resistant to the inroads of institutionalisation, technology and the market. Perhaps he also saw in me a priest like himself, one who in time had become disillusioned by the institutional church, but who was still fired by the ideals of the gospel.
On the day Ivan died, Monday December 2nd 2002, I had the feeling that his soul travelled to Aran and hovered over our house sometime between 7 p.m. and 11 p.m. Doubtless he was on his way to Scellig Michael, the monastic island off County Kerry, where souls are gathered by the archangel Michael to prepare for their journey to heaven.

Dara Molloy is co-editor of The AISLING Magazine.

Lee Hoinacki and Carl Mitcham are the editors of a timely new book on Ivan Illich entitled The Challenges of Ivan Illich. It is a collection of reflective essays on the work of Illich.

Wayne Northey (and friends)

Wayne Northey

May 19, 2014, from Wayne: Has CBC pulled together all your online broadcasts?  That would be a worthy venture.  I for one would be directing people to them all - as I often do to various in any event...

May 20, 2014, from David: I wouldn't say pulled together no.  I have more the impression of having sunk without a trace…..A number of things are still on-line, but I think that's mainly inertia.  I'm afraid that it's all just Content, and that nobody really sees that what I did over the years constitutes either a resource worth preserving or even a coherent body of work.  However your question is timely, and I will keep thinking about how to keep my work available to those who might find it helpful.

May 20, 2014, from Ron Dart: Over the years, I numerous times direct people to your broadcasts by going to an online CBC link, copying and pasting it into the e-mail for instant access. I'm populating now a personal website.  I do that same thing in the documents themselves (MS Word allows such "hotkeying"), and on WordPress, the backdoor software used for the website. It's easy to use html code to do that for online publication...  You'll see it all over on my website.

Though I have only listened to a small portion of your overall broadcast work, some quick observations:

  • there is coherence of themes at many levels, as wide-ranging as your subjects are, not least of course your consistent (literal) "voice" throughout.

  • topics you have chosen over the decades, thanks to previous producers so I understand, according to primarily what interested you.  Those interests could readily be basis of a Master's or Ph.D thesis on David Cayley's "Ideas" (double entendre).  They do form a vast "body of work" to be discovered by many, abundantly well worth it. 

  • art form: radio broadcasting, for all Ivan Illich's misgivings around the technology of it, is a unique art form.  My friends and I out here are agreed: you have elevated that art form significantly over your decades of broadcasting.  (I cannot compare widely to prove that, I/we can only "witness" to its effect on me/us.)  I know this: it is rare gift that another's ideas can be taken, rebundled, and literally broadcast with such (often for me greater) clarity and impact into the anonymous audience airwaves.   C. S. Lewis for one had that rare gift...  I even possess a series of radio broadcast cassettes he did on the "Four Loves".  That's how your series on Nils Christie years ago impacted me, and every experience since...  (I first contacted you with appreciation after that series, and have been so grateful for our friendship since.)  Others have done/do it well at "Ideas" and elsewhere.  But few with such impact, I speak experientially.  Your broadcasts "satisfy"...  Much more can readily be said.

  • on any level, such a body of work should not be lost (that's why you're continuing to work on Ivan Illich's body of work!), let alone be allowed to be "sunk without a trace".

  • The weekend (first one of February) after my last day of work (retired officially March 31 this year - party for that this Saturday - you're welcome to drop in - ha!) we visited Roy Henry Vickers' art studio in Tofino.  Besides loving his work over the years, I love his brief introductions/stories to the genesis of every painting!  Such as it is, I've taken that as model on the website a friend developed for me and I'm populating with alacrity: I'm telling the genesis story most times.  That's invaluable to some (however large or small the circle, right?)  It's ubiquitous of course that we all want such accounts.  

In light of all that, a proposal of sorts:

  • if CBC will not pull your works together, surely you have right of access to all the archived material - perhaps have them at your home anyway.

  • why not make them available for digitilization (even I have the software and hardware to do that flawlessly - and have done so with 30 years of home video for instance - so not very high end technical know-how needed!)?  Much over the last many years of your work is already digitalized.

  • why not offer it as a body of work to UFV for instance (Ron are you listening)?  A techy Masters student on a  Work Grant could digitalize and categorize everything, in turn then it could be made available ultimately online, thus to the world as a "body of work" by a significant CBC Ideas broadcaster.  You could interactively introduce all the works, making the "coherence" connections to your heart's content, as you have time and interest.   Then, an annual lecture series in your honour could be initiated by UFV that you would speak at each until your death (you are "advancing" in years of course!.  In that case: written into the contract of course would be an "Institute" on the side at our place... :-) )

Something like that.  Then when my grandson (okay, he's only 12 now, but a bright kid!) is casting about for a Master's or a Ph.D thesis, I have just the project for him! :-)

I really am, all lightness aside, dead serious, David!

I'm guessing that you have one or more techy grandkids who could do that digitalization project, and could get a grant to do it as a Summer job, or whatever, with even a tiny bit (surely!) of CBC backing...

Anyway... Glad about the After Atheism rebroadcast.  Glad that you will "keep thinking" - I mean about such a project as above ...  I rather think you will "keep thinking" regardless.  "David Cayley on David Cayley" is so worthwhile however it comes out!

May 21, 2014, from David: dear Wayne,  thanks for words of praise and for the attention you've devoted to the whole issue. The main things I got out of my blessed years at Ideas was a lot of splendid friends, as you've just proved once again.

         Up 'til now, I've been hoping, without reason, that CBC Radio will want to do something to preserve my work and make it available, since that is now so easily done.  However I haven't taken any steps to promote the idea.  So I guess, if I'm serious, exploring that avenue should be my first move.  The second possibility is to make it available though a web-site of my own. . …..You've now suggested a third possibility - that someone else would do it.  I find this an appealing idea, as might CBC Radio, but I don't know if it's very likely to fly.

        Anyway thank you for the encouragement, and the nudge to get me going on this.  It may be fall before I begin to follow up, but I will.

P.S. I do have a complete sound archive, some of it already digitalized, and transcriptions of all shows between 1982 when we began transcription and 2006 when the CBC lost interest and could no longer understand why a print record might have a unique value (e.g. citability, and easy reference) in a world of proliferating "platforms" - God save us.  

May 21, 2014, from  Brad Jersak: Dear David, Brad Jersak weighing in here with my 'amen.' About 18 months ago, I finished writing my PhD (under Ron Dart's supervision) on George Grant and Simone Weil. Throughout that process, I think I bought or read virtually everything on or by Grant and I must say that your George Grant in Conversation was by far the most helpful, dog-eared and highlighted resource on my bookshelf. Your poignant questions drew out answers from Grant available nowhere else and probably saved me either hundreds of hours or hundreds of mistakes.

Then onto the After Atheism series ... I know both Girard and Caputo personally, and can't honestly think of a close second to your fair and accurate summaries of their work. Simply the best out there ... and actually, the piece on Kearney was my favourite. I've passed it on to friends for whom it virtually saved their faith and others who needed the recovery message. Thank you so much! 

I'm 'gutted' to hear that your visit out west would be while I'm at Nottingham for post-doc work this fall, but please know that all of us hear recognize your long-term faithfulness to the Good. This is what is driving all these inquiries.

May 22, 2014, from Wayne: Given you have the complete sound archive, that so much is already digitalized, it is not a huge stretch to have a website done up by a professional designer (I asked such at our church to do mine, and am pleased with the outcome.  The $900 or so was worth it, and the $15/month keeps everything actively secured, etc... - check it out below if you wish); and the uploading of digitalized material - or any kind of file - is a piece of cake.  I'm doing it all the time through back door software called "WordPress", for instance - with commentary.  Lots of fun!

I wonder that it is best to have a grandkid or some such do all that in your home - so there is no chance of loss of the material.  Software and hardware are cheap, and flawless, provided you can hook up the tape player of the master tape to a USB port on a computer.  Digitalized also means a more permanent record.  Even more so once uploaded to a website...

Enough said.  There is huge benefit in completing such a project!  Man: I'll be listening on my old iPhone/now ipod anytime I travel on my own... am now to some of the earlier ones!  

May 22, 2014, from David: Dear Brad, thanks for your letter.  George Grant - I think it's in Grant in  Conversation - remembered hearing Leo Strauss advise teachers to remember that among their auditors there might, at any given moment, be someone more attentive, more ardent, more serious than they.  (That's not exact - I'm paraphrasing.)  I always remembered that, and it was borne out again and again when I would learn, sometimes years after the fact, how much something I had written or said on the CBC had meant to someone else, perhaps even more than it had meant to me - and all unknown to me at the time.  (Broadcasting can be unhappily promiscuous, but it does have this resemblance to the sower of the parable as well.)  Anyway I'm very happy to know that various works of mine were helpful to you, and, through you, to others.  I hope we'll meet up one day.

March 21, 2024, from Wayne: Our enterprising pastor, Ian Funk (copied), at Langley Mennonite Fellowship has asked 5 of us to preach over the next month or so, each based on one of the After Atheism series. He did not know before of my connection to you. I've agreed to do the first one of the series: Richard Kearney. I told you once how much in an existentially difficult time external to me. [….] I happened to listen to the first airing on CBC after a difficult board meeting, and felt refreshed as I pulled into the driveway an hour later! Again, thank you!

A few things:

  • are there any manuscripts available from any of that series?

  • can you point me to anything more current about Richard Kearney? I'll also be looking. Or to any of the others interviewed?

  • would you be open to do a Zoom call about the series, where essentially you'd do the talking? It could be made available on the LMF YouTube channel, for those interested. You might wish to explain how you came to do the series, why it was divided into 2 sections, and what overall you were getting at in these two, as it turned out, last of your broadcasts on Ideas.

This should not involve more work, other than the Zoom time. But fully understood if it does not work for you. If you agree, presumably you would be open to have it posted both on LMF's site, and on mine?

Finally, you recall that (Anglican) scholar Ron Dart took part in our Ivan Illich book discussions. He retired last year after almost 40 years of teaching at University of the Fraser Valley. Some of us undertook to produce a Liber Amicorum (his choice over just an academic Festschrift), and I've completed the second round of copy-editing (first done by another friend, Matthew Steem, who also participated in that Illich group of discussions), also completed all the formatting, and am waiting only for another friend (Brad Jersak) to add ISBNs to each cover of the two-volume set (which he did in the first place), then publishing on Kindle Direct Publishing: one totalling 1,059 pages!

Ron is one of the relatively unsung Canadian-oriented academics whom retired Political Science prof, John Redekop, calls in the tome a "Renaissance Man." There are 82 contributors. It will appear as a two-volume set, titled:The Scholar-Gipsy: Thrownness, Memoricide & The Great Tradition .

Attached Quotes and Pieces from Wayne

Mar 23, 2024, from David: Dear Wayne, nice to hear from you.  I'm delighted to hear that those broadcasts are inspiring sermons, and especially one by you.

         There is no transcript of the series.  But the time it was broadcasting, the CBC, over my strenuous but unavailing objections, had discontinued transcripts.

          I've had no contact with Richard since the Illich book was published.  I had a copy sent to him in hopes of a review, and he said he would have his most recent book - on touch, as I recall - sent to me.  I never got his book, and he never produced a review so far as I know, and there the matter stands.  I did an earlier series with Richard, as you probably know, called The God Who May Be, which surveyed his work up to the time of the broadcast in 2006.  The three programs are on my site, and there is a transcript of that one on the transcripts page. 

           I'd be happy to do a Zoom call.  Might you interview me, just so I have someone to talk to, rather than my just having to orate into the void?  I'm very happy to know of your tribute to Ron Dart.  I know shockingly little of his work - hard to keep up - but we're still in touch from time to time, and perhaps I'll catch up one day.  

Mar 24, 2024, from Wayne: It's definitely a great idea to lift off from the broadcasts in brief, pithy sermons -- Ian Funk's hope. I'll happily send you mine, though have no clue yet about what I'll present.

I think you had mentioned before CBC's failure to keep doing transcripts. Such a shame. Yes, I know of your earlier series, but never had accessed it. I have now downloaded the transcripts. checked Kearney's Boston College website. He has not been idle! There you will find this clickable list, that I quickly scanned tonight:

Books

Recent Books
Trilogy: Philosophy at the Limit
Other Books
Essay Monographs
Fiction & Poetry
Edited Volumes
Chapters & Articles in Books
Books on Kearney’s Work
Translations of Kearney’s Work

Thanks for your willingness to do a Zoom for subsequent posting. I did chuckle at the thought of my interviewing you. . .

But I have an idea: were we to wait until the series is done (see list below), then we collectively could take an hour or so "Zooming" with you about it. Some of the more general questions--as already mentioned--I could pose after introducing you and them. Then we presenters may each have questions for you that arise from our talks, possibly limiting it to three or something like that. This way, as we prepare the "sermons", we could think of questions to ask you on Zoom later. Then, we could have a general discussion, given that many may listen to all five, and unless truant (shame on them!), all will have listened to each other, so that a more informed discussion might take place. (Of course we may all listen to the recordings anytime, too!) I think this would create definite interest for several in our congregation, once posted to, and promoted on, the YouTube channel. And I'll also post it on my website.

The premise of the proposal is of course that Ian and the others think this an okay idea. I'll defer initially to Ian on this (he does two of them), and see if we proceed from there. (Ian: no feelings hurt if you think we shouldn't do this. I'm fine if not, and David, who is so gracious, I'm sure agrees.)
Following is the series, as described by Ian:
As you know, we are working with the radio series After Atheism.  This is a new link to the series.  https://www.davidcayley.com/podcasts/category/After+Atheism.  We will begin with an introductory Sunday on April 7.  I will speak about how the disciples, when in hiding after Jesus' crucifixion/resurrection, mourned the death of the Christ they knew, and were now getting reacquainted with a risen Christ and anticipating the leading of the Holy Spirit. Moving from there, I propose the following;

April 14 Lisa will respond to John Caputo (Program 2).  She has chosen Acts 15 as the scripture for April 14
April 21  Ian will respond to Roger Lundin (Program 5)  Scripture TBD
April 28  Wayne will respond to Richard Kearney (Program 1)  Scripture TBD
May 5  Ian will respond to William Cavanaugh (Program 3)  Scripture TBD
May 12  Juliet will respond to James Carse (Program 4)  Scripture TBD

Just some initial thoughts.

As to Ron Dart. Here are links to the Kindle versions of the two-volume set, which I've made free for five days:
The Scholar-Gipsy Volume 1: Thrownness, Memoricide & The Great Tradition
The Scholar-Gipsy Volume 2: Thrownness, Memoricide & The Great Tradition 
——

Apr 11, 2024, from Ian: Hello Wayne, Hello David, I just thought that I'd chime in and thank you both, Wayne for creatively thinking of generative possibilities, and David for responding generously to Wayne's suggestion that we have a Q & A on Zoom.  I am open to any good interaction that we might have.  A Zoom meeting, mid May would be great!!

David, I've been listening to the After Atheism series a few times now and appreciate them greatly.  Our series begins this Sunday.  I am sorry, logistics determined that we respond to each of the episodes but out of order; I hope that the cohesion and flow of the series isn't too disrupted by this.

We are calling our worship series; God. Then & Now; Always and Eternal, hopefully conveying that God/church looks and is different through time while the lasting/sustaining qualities of God and religious life remain.  I am hoping this title offers some assurance of unchangeability while not softening too much our challenge of the status quo; some are truly traumatised by change, or even the prospect of it.
Nonetheless, there is a keen interest at Langley Mennonite to know a living, present and relevant God who speaks to us in real and meaningful ways.  Many of us also understand that we need to deconstruct and relearn to get there.  There is also an anxious (yet vibrant) sense that we don't know what new looks like or how to do new stuff...so that's the spirit that brought us to After Atheism.  Some have already expressed excitement and intrigue over the upcoming series...so I am excited too.  We will have 5 speakers respond to the 5 episodes, most of whom have been called from the pew to speak.  You're invited to listen in if you ever are interested.



Brother John, Taize

Brother John, Mar 14, 2022


Dear David,

Profiting from some days alone in Italy and inspired by a second reading of your book, I wrote the article about Illich and apocalypse that you suggested. I'm sending it along to you, because I have no idea what to do with it. Personally I don't have access to any journals or publications that would publish it. If you have ideas, wonderful.

You'll see that I take issue to a certain extent with your own reading of the New Testament. I think Illich is far closer to the Book of Revelation than you (or perhaps even he) thought. But we agree on everything else, and I don't need to say again how indebted I am to your book to show me the unity of Illich's thought.
——
David, Mar 15, 2022,

Dear John,

         I was happy to receive your letter and happier still with your "Apocalypse Now." 

        As to what you say, I think we essentially agree, although emphasizing different aspects of John's apocalypse.  [Revelations is] a book that makes me uneasy from the outset - the failings of the seven churches that are in Asia - and that feeling - that a spirit of schadenfreude and revenge is at work in the background - never really leaves me.  I'm sure that influences my reading, as does the reception history of the book.  I know it can be read as you do and all the violence, and swords in teeth, etc. resolved into symbolism, and I'm respectful of that reading.  "Mythological" might have been an ill-judged word on my part - I was struggling for a term to convey what Ivan accepted and what he didn't accept.  It was probably also clumsy to call him a non-apocalyptic thinker, even if I specified the sense in which I spoke, since I clearly think he is an apocalyptic thinker through and through, and I am delighted by your designating his work as a whole as a contemporary apocalypse.

       Many thanks to you for this essay.  There has been little engagement so far with the aspects of the book you take up, and I think they are crucial in understanding Illich.  May I also share your essay with a reading group here in Canada that has been meeting monthly by Zoom to discuss the book?  The Apocalypse chapter is on the agenda for this month, and I'd like to throw your essay into the discussion.

all best for now,

David

——

Brother John, Jun 26, 2025

Dear David,

It was great to see you in Lucca and glad you made it home safely.….. I promised to send the manuscript I completed on the man-woman dichotomy in the Bible, a thorny subject today if there ever was one. My conclusion is "equal but different" which may dissatisfy everyone. Don't know if and when it will be published so I send you the manuscript.

——

David, Jun 26, 2025

Dear John,

I'm glad to have your manuscript. Thank you. I'll have it printed out next time I'm by my favourite copy shop. I can only stand so much screen reading. I'm sure it will advance my thinking. Do you know the passage in The Rivers North of the Future - on p. 198, if you have it - in which Ivan explains Hugh of St. Victor's account of why "male and female [God] created them" and his own idea of "dysymmetrical complementarity"?

——

Tue, May 26, 2026 12:44 PM

Dear John,

I've read your book, your comments on my Jung essay, and the First Things article on Jung's Gnosticism that you linked.

Springtime, first of all, is wonderful – wonderfully concise, which I appreciated, but also inspiring. It agrees very well with part of my understanding of Ivan's corruptio as a call to return to the source. You emphasize more the disintegration of "Christian" civilization, while he talks more of its perverse fulfillment, but I think there is a lot of agreement there.

The disagreement appears more in your comments on my Jung essay, and, a fortiori, in Satinover's critique of Jung. I want to say first that I don’t think Jung is a consistent thinker, or a man with a “system.” But, of course, he did elaborate a system of a sort, and a vocabulary to go with it, and I think that generates a lot of confusions and misunderstanding, and opens the door for cramped, hostile misreadings of the kind which I think Satinover is sometimes guilty. For me, as I think I said in that essay, Jung is a Christian who is trying to understand what that means in view of the crisis of faith that he already observed in his parent’s generation. And he is a pilgrim soul – a man in process, if you like - who is trying to use a language - science - which is often refractory to his purposes but which he sometimes succeeds in enlarging in promising ways.

I think I probably identify with Jung as someone who feels himself to be in the same situation. I was deeply steeped in Anglican Christianity as a boy, so much so that it became, I would say, the very structure, or substructure of my understanding. But, as my horizons widened, what I had understood was subject to challenges that I could barely grasp, let alone respond to. Jung’s Aion, like Bonhoeffer’s (very different) prison letters, pushed me to the thought of a new age – of a reformulation and a reworking of what had been handed over to us in the light of an increasingly apocalyptic reality.

The essay that you read is an attempt to bring what I took from Ivan into consonance with this earlier intuition on which Jung had such an influence. I was very conscious in writing it that I was working at the limits of my understanding, and certainly at the limits of what I could express in intelligible sentences. In responding you have made a distinction between the God image and the Living God, to whom, you say, only Jesus offers perfect access. But I wonder about this distinction. Doesn’t it tend to disqualify what appears to the seeker who can’t know in advance what he’s seeking, and put God – as the “living God” – securely into the exclusive possession of those with faith? Isn’t the living God mediated by the images we form, even if they seem to form themselves? Jung, in his explorations during the First World War, working at the edge of what might easily have been madness, didn’t know what he was doing. I would say he put himself into the hands of the living God with unusual courage, and gave testimony to the complacent of how terrible the living God can be.

Jung said that because he lacked faith, he was thrown back on experience. That’s a way of speaking. But what do we mean by faith and what by experience? If God and humanity change in relation to one another – the bold supposition that Jung shares with Eckhart and others in his lineage – then can faith be said to apprehend some unchanging essence? Experience is an equally layered word, and a very confusing one in Jung because of his real, but also pretended, empiricism.

You imagine a new age of the church, and I think that is right. The Church was the first intuition of a universal community, and must somehow be the incipient or ghostly form of the coming community. But how? We have intuitions, like Illich’s “powerless,” declericalized church, Bonhoeffer’s religionless Christianity, or Rosenstock-Huessy’s “unlabelled…listening church” (in his wonderful The Christian Future, or the Modern Mind Outrun – I’ve take a crack at an introduction to the little known R.H. here: https://www.davidcayley.com/blog/2025/6/2/rosentock-huessy) But these are only hints, and reachings after something untried and unknown. More will not be discovered without epistemic humility – a real, and not merely pretended state of not knowing.

Jung’s claims – for quadernity over trinity, for the inclusion of evil, matter and the feminine element in God, for a new style of “imitation” of Christ – are guesses, probes, as McLuhan’s says, explorations in a language that will hardly bear the weight of what it’s being asked to carry. I entertain these claims – odd word – test them – try to see through them or with them. I don’t say that I know what is the case. It’s the confident tone – Satinover sometimes gives examples of it – that needs to be dispelled in favour of the questioning tone, but the questioning tone – firm and tentative at the same time – is just as elusive as the future church.

Is the Gospel a closed book, the Incarnation a last word, or is there more still to be disclosed – a more towards which we can dispose ourselves in humility and attentive anticipation, but whose arrival we can’t hurry or force? Nicolas of Cusa says – if I’ve understood him correctly in his The Vision of God - that at the wall of paradise, which I take to mean the extremity of our discursive understanding, God appears as a coincidentia oppositorum. I’m not sure Jung says any more than this. To say that God contains, or even is, evil seems bizarre, and obviously Gnostic, in the despised and rejected sense of that word. And yet…does Ivan not confess to a temptation to “curse the Incarnation” when he contemplates the mystery of evil, and does he not come within a hair of saying that this mystery is inherent in the Incarnation and can therefore be understood as the will of God?

That’s where I am…at least as well as I can tell you in a short letter which I must now bring to an end. I’m glad to be in conversation with you.

In friendship,

David

——

May 28, 2026, Dear David,

Thanks for your reply. I appreciate your remarks on my latest manuscript and that you see it as basically consonant with Illich’s thought, from a different perspective. Coming from you, that means a lot.

To continue our discussion, I’d like to clarify my distinction between “the God-image” and “the living God,” which seemed problematic to you, if I understood correctly. From certain things you say in your latest letter, I don’t think our positions are that far apart. Let me try again.

First of all, I certainly don’t think that, as you put it, my outlook “tend[s] to disqualify what appears to the seeker who can’t know in advance what he’s seeking, and put God – as the ‘living God’ – securely into the exclusive possession of those with faith.” I don’t think those who consider themselves believers, nor the church as a whole, have any more of a monopoly on who God definitively is than anyone else. What they (we) have is rather the conviction that the revelation who God is in him/her/itself inevitably passes through the figure of Jesus the Christ.

And so for us the question also becomes “Who is Jesus?” The church(es) have sometimes acted as if they had a monopoly on knowing the identity of Jesus, and a complete knowledge of that identity, but I think that is incorrect. (In the gospels already the first disciples often got it wrong.) What I call “the living God” is so far beyond what our minds can capture—and therefore Jesus as the revealer of God is equally more than we imagine at any given moment—that we are all permanently seekers.

To put it in human terms, I would compare, analogically, the distinction between the God-image and the living God with the case of someone with whom we gradually establish a friendship. After meeting that person, we have an image of them in our mind. As the relationship grows, we refine that image, discarding some previous ideas and “getting to know them better,” as we would say. But the way we see that person is never simply identical to that person as they are in themselves. They are the “limit case,” to put it in mathematical terms, that we approach asymptotically.

This leads to the question of Jung’s own personal beliefs. I fully agree that he was not the builder of a hard-and-fast system, but rather a seeker with an amazing knowledge of all kinds of trends and thinkers. That, paradoxically, makes it harder to grasp where he stood, because one can find all sorts of quotes by him that seem to go in different directions. You see him as “a Christian who is trying to understand what that means in view of the crisis of faith that he already observed in his parent’s generation.” You may be right, and you certainly have read more Jung than I have, but there seem to be other quotes where he calls himself an agnostic or even someone interested in creating, out of the fragments of Christianity, a new religion relevant to our day. Naturally people are allowed to evolve, and do not always explain their thinking adequately, but the key question here seems to me to be the following:

Either one believes that God is a Reality beyond our understanding but existing in him/her/itself, that we have somehow encountered and which we can try and know more deeply, like the friend I talked about earlier, in which case all of our searching—based in part on our own experience, and for Christians in part on the witness of other believers across the ages, beginning with the Bible—is helpful, necessary and never-ending (no one has a monopoly).

Or else we don’t believe in that God who exists, or are not sure if there is anything “out there” independent of the human condition at all, and then it is logical to focus on the God-image in our minds, based on our experience and that of others. But, in the end, is that not just something we create, unless we have an inkling that there is something beyond our creation?

Here we come to the “epistemic humility” you mention; it is essential, and it is just as arduous for the non-believer as it is for the believer, though for different reasons. For both groups, to use my language, it is hard not to equate our God-image with the living God beyond our minds.

(By the way, I too found the Sandover article a little bit deficient in that humility. His tone is a bit too ex cathedra, too knowing. But I thought he had some good insights. I had the sense that he saw in Jung himself different outlooks that made him hard to categorize, though I may be wrong.)

So, to the extent that Jung was indeed a Christian trying to find a better way of understanding what it means to believe today, more power to him. If instead he saw the Christian view of reality as a kind of raw material that he could recompose into something more congenial to his own personal worldview, in the end that is less helpful for people like me.

I do realize that some Christian theologians—and here you and I probably differ—would agree, as you say, that “God and humanity change in relation to one another.” I’ve never gotten into Meister Eckhart, so I don’t know really what he meant, but certainly someone like Jürgen Moltmann might say that. To me that all goes back to Hegel, and it seems to me highly dubious.

I am not a Thomist per se, but I remain convinced that God is God and, though deeply involved with creation to the point of becoming one of us, God cannot change in his/her/its ultimate essence or identity, what the tradition calls his transcendence. I concede, to go back to my analogy with a human person (and it is only an analogy), that in a relationship we cause aspects of the personality of the other, previously only implicit, to be revealed, but nonetheless the person exists independently of the relationship.

This brings us to another question, that of the Incarnation and its meaning. But that is for another time.

Thanks again for giving me the opportunity to share thoughts.

John

PS After writing all this, I had a thought which I have no way of verifying, since I am not so acquainted with Jung’s life. I wondered if the problem many have of “classifying” him regarding his beliefs might not be due to the fact that not only did he evolve during his life, but that there was a real struggle in him between someone faithful to the Christian faith and someone in reaction against it and trying to replace it. It would be fascinating to see if one could demonstrate this from his biography.

PPS Thanks for the link to your introduction to Eugen Rosenstock-Huessy. I started reading his book The Christian Future some time ago and got bogged down.

Jun 8, 2026, David

Dear John,

Here I am at last - with an answer to your last letter. Thanks for trying to clarify the issue we've been discussing.

Jung is various and changing, as we've both now said, but I'm interested mainly in the old man, who wrote once to a young scholar who inquired about something he had said forty years before about "the incredible folly that filled the days of my youth”- perhaps I cite this remark in my essay. My sources are mainly Aion, Answer to Job, and the letters, particularly the ones that Edward Edinger collected in a useful book called The New God-Image (Chiron, 1996). There seems to me to be no doubt that, for Jung, at this late period, God is real, or that, as you say, "God is God." Peter Kingsley even quotes him as saying that he wants to "let God be God" free of human projection. The last words of Answer to Job, where he speaks of “the One who dwells within [us], whose form has no knowable boundaries, who encompasses [us] on all sides, fathomless as the abysms of the earth and vast as the sky,” could have come from the mouth of the Psalmist. A "within us" that at the same time "encompasses us" without height, depth or limit, is not what we normally mean by "within" or by "subjectivity." These and other passages seem to me to bespeak an encounter with the living God, rather than an attempt, in your words, "to recompose [God] into something more congenial."

On the other hand there is no doubt that for Jung, a "new God-image" is an intelligible idea, though the phrase is Edinger's, not Jung's. He says that our image of God must be revised to include elements that have been excluded from God - matter, evil and the feminine essentially - and that quadernity is preferable to a trinity as an image of the divine. And he seems broadly sympathetic to the ideas he encounters in various mystical and esoteric literatures that humanity and God are finally inseparable, and even, when the idea is stated in its boldest form, like Hegel's saying that God's knows himself as a self-consciousness in man , or Silesius's "without me God can no moment live," that God becomes conscious in humanity.

These positions - that God is something that happens to us, not something we invent, but is also something that happens to us progressively, and in changing forms, through time - are reconciled for Jung in the figure of psyche, or as he sometimes says "objective psyche" - in order to stress exactly the element you're insisting on - that God "exists in his/her/itself." When psyche is translated into "psychology," and psychology into some sort of art of self-care and self-manipulation, and Jung himself is not blameless here, a lot of what is helpful in Jung's conception of psyche gets lost.

I wrote the essay I sent you to see if I could make my intuition that Illich, in his conception of "a mystery of evil," that shadows the Incarnation, and is, for all intents and purposes, inherent in it, can be related to Jung's suggestion that Christianity is not a finished structure - a story foretold that only awaits its inevitable dénouement - but rather a continuing revelation. I have that intuition - it is a germ, or a seed, or a bud of some kind - but I lack the language, and, in part, the confidence, to carry it much farther forward than I have done. That's why interlocutors like you are important to me at this stage.

I think perhaps that's all I can say at this point. Please don't feel any obligation to respond punctually. I'll be happy to hear from you, if you have something you want to tell me. And I'll certainly be in touch with you when I have more to say.

A warm embrace to you in the meanwhile,

David

More

Clarke Mackey

Apr 5, 2026,from Clarke Mackey to David: Thanks so much for sending this fascinating essay. It makes me want to revisit Jung’s ideas and explore some of the other thinkers you mention.

      In the ‘70s, when I was an undergraduate at U of T, my friends and I began reading Freud and Jung (along with R. D. Laing and his associates). I became obsessed with these ideas for several years. I think it was because it helped provide explanations for the confusing disjuncture between the intentions and actions in myself and those around me.

      When my girlfriend and I made the budget grand tour of hostels through Europe in 1977, I dragged her to Zurich and Vienna so that I could stand where my heroes had lived. (At that time, Freud’s old apartment was a museum, but there was nothing commemorating Jung. Now his house is a museum as well.)

      I knew there were important differences between Freud and Jung. At the time, I was attracted to Jung’s greater openness to non-western practices and beliefs, the para-normal, and other unpopular ideas. Acceptance of the mysteries of existence. Awareness of the limits of science.

      In general, I find the idea of a God that is both good and evil intuitively correct, and the all-good Christ and Christianity as a serious flaw of the official church. I am sympathetic to the arguments you are putting forward. I’ve never read Hegel, but I suspect, given what I’ve heard, that he and his followers might find some agreement with you on the dialectical nature of God and the need to rethink faith in light of current conditions.

      I’ll be curious to hear what your interlocutors have to say about this essay.

April 17, 2026, from David to Clarke: I was glad to hear that you are in sympathy with Jung's basic idea. One of the great difficulties of discussing this question lies in the fact that God is often conceived, and spoken of, and to, as a person, and it then becomes hard to allow that God might be a bad person, whom we have some right to judge. This is a sound objection in certain ways, and to answer it requires a distinction between Jung's experiential language and more theological languages.

My friend Sajay intends to publish the essay in a special issue of Conspiratio - the little journal that so far serves the community of Illich friends - https://thinkingwithivanillich.net/ - and I hope that will stimulate more discussion. So far, excepting yourself and a couple of others, I seem to have mainly faced hostility, incomprehension, or indifference.

——

——

Chrissy Reichert

(From Jutta) A parcel arrived in the mail from Chrissy Reichert, who until two years ago helped me in the house and the garden, and who worked to help us bring structure and grace to some family gatherings and also to some community gatherings when those were temporarily illegal due to the public health rules.

The parcel contained three sets of garden gloves, a secateur, a package of herb tea, a copy of C.S.Lewis’ book on his grief, and a card with a collage of David playing the guitar plus a vase of flowers (another little picture of birds flying on the back of the envelope), and this text:

July 13, 2026, from Chrissy: First time I heard his voice was in 2001 in a tiny apartment that had one window facing a brick wall, and it was dreadful. One of the good memories (before I had a computer) was listening to the radio and the only thing I remember was David’s “The Scapegoat” series with Renee Girard. It was so valuable to me at that time, and I never forgot it.

Then in 2012 I met a girl during a show and she mentioned “The Scapegoat” series & we bonded and were so excited to talk about it. Who knew that I would have the privilege to meet this wonderful broadcaster and his beautiful wife, and be working with them for several years Who knew that I would meet his entire family, witness his daily rituals of coffee and the newspaper with his wife, then upstairs to write, the down for lunch & see his love for sports & fellowship with his beloved. Who knew I would get to witness his love for family & friends, to get to see his beautiful floral arrangements, to find out what things were on his mind, & what he was working on, & see his cool little work space, art on the walls & wonderful book collection. To see his love and admiration for his wife, and daughter Kate, because it was very obvious how in love he was. And that I would get to share Christmas with him & his family, & sing the most beautiful carols, ones I never even heard at church. And that this man would come to one of my music shows, before my own father would, and that we would survive a weird pandemic. Who knew that I would fall in love with him& his family. Thank you Lord.”

Sept.18, 2026, from Chrissy: The garden has also served as a counsellor and witness regarding the matters of God  to me over the years, over and over, Jesus taught me many things there.

  1. When the beautiful rock path was covered and settled in mud and leaves, I would use that lopsided green tool to scrape away, until slowly but surely the beautiful rock came to the surface, and finished the rest of the delicate work with my hands. I did this with each stone. It would seem like I was not doing very much until I saw the unveiled path behind me. This made me think of the scripture "Prepare the way for the Lord!". Show that beneath the dirt and rubble, there is a distinct path to God. Do it stone by stone.

  1. There was the time when I came to work in your garden and found what appeared to be the tiniest dead baby raccoon at the side of your house. We thought it may have fallen off of your roof. I was very upset because you know I love animals, especially little babies. He wasn't moving and didn't appear to be breathing. You were going to get someone to throw it in the garbage later, and so I went to the garden to work, but was pretty sad about it. Later on, towards the end of my shift, I saw this precious little baby raccoon walk slowly towards the garden, and he looked okay! I believed I had just witnessed a miracle! Was it really a miracle? I believe it was. Why not?

  2. When David found out about his heart condition during COVID, and he had gone to Fiona for holistic medicinal advice, she had suggested adding kale to his diet. That year Jutta, you had a forest of kale in the garden. It was more than I had ever seen you have in all the years I worked for you. I thought, "The Lord Provides."

  3. When I would trim the wisteria, I would accidentally get pricked by the thorns on the roses close by, and was surprised by how one tiny prick was so painful. I imagined what it might have felt like for Jesus to wear a crown of thorns.

  4. The soil was rich and black, full of worms and life and it was the place to be. There was life, and everybody was participating: the birds, the butterflies, the robin, the service tree, the bees, the flowers, the herbs, the vegetables. When I went to do weeding for another client, who had a well-manicured, mostly cosmetic garden, I noticed the soil. It was dry and rocky. It made me think about the scripture "Break up your fallow ground and do not sow among thorns" (Jeremiah 4:3), and how thorns represent the cares of this world. And I thought about how Jesus's church was probably meant to function like this garden, and our hearts needed to look like this soil. 

Stuff like that.

——

——

From John Milbank to Jutta, Jul 6, 2026: Although David passed away in such good circumstances, he was far too young to die for these days, and was such a remarkable person. It was a real privilege to know him and he helped and encouraged me enormously. Without him surely Ivan Illich’s thought would not have reached its crucial final form. David was far more than a mere promoter; in the end more a co-elaborator. Along with Charles Taylor, Illich’s legacy is surely now much indebted to Canadians!

Ideas, John Milbank, The Myth of the Secular, Part Six, Radical Orthodoxy

——

——

From Phillip Mesley to Jutta, July 30, 2026

In the summer of 2021, a group of friends met regularly in Toronto parks, seated on blankets the approved 1 meter apart, to discuss David Cayley’s recently published Ivan Illich: An Intellectual Journey. Our group was not homogeneous: a recently ordained minister, a teacher, a gardener, a social worker, a human rights advocate, and a grad student, we were rarely in agreement, and certainly not all committed Illichians. I had been reading Illich for a few years by then and knew of David through his two books of interviews with him. He emerged as a distinct person for me when I came across his “Questions About the Pandemic” and, on a whim, decided to send him a response. What I found so refreshing in this text was not solely the ideas he threw out, but the expression of an earnest desire to discuss what was happening. I had observed how uncomfortable I made people in those days when I sought to debate the pros and cons of lockdowns, and in response I kept my views to myself or my closest friends. David announced his confusion publicly and dared others to take up the challenge to explain this new historical event to him.

Since that initial contact, I’ve gone through most of David’s archive of CBC Ideas documentaries (which he graciously made freely available on his website) and it is clear that the spirit of his “Questions” fits within a larger pattern. In the interviews he recorded with prominent thinkers of his age—Richard Sennett, René Girard, George Grant, and many others—he performed an incalculable service for future generations. But, despite what even he was probably inclined to think, this service was not limited to sussing out from them an elucidation of their thinking, but involved an actively creative exchange. In this, he revealed the meaning of “speech-thinking,” a notion developed by philosophers Franz Rosenzweig and Eugen Rosenstock-Huessy which David himself only encountered late in life and whose proponents he described as follows: “They are able to know what they think only through the intermediation of some interlocutor. Their thoughts do not already exist in some pure and essential form in advance of their expression – they take shape in an encounter with some other on whom they depend and for whom they can only wait and hope.” David could reasonably have described his vocation (or job title) as that of interlocutor. Such a task cannot be accomplished by a neutral interrogator; it requires a grappling partner.

David’s persistence, a simultaneous intuitive grasp and stubborn incomprehension, were the necessary condition for getting thinkers to develop as fully as possible their ideas, while trusting that they were speaking to a sincere and interested person. When confronted with an idea he could not comprehend, he did the opposite of what many of us do: he doubled down in his quest to understand it, asking more questions, soliciting more opportunities to talk it over, getting more perspectives to weigh in and resting unsatisfied until he felt convinced that he had truly mastered it. Some highlights from his radio career, for me, are his series on Simone Weil (featuring his daughter Kate giving truly breathtaking readings of Weil); “Being Born,” a report on the wacky and niche field of prenatal psychology; and of course the conversations that would make up The Rivers North of the Future.

When I reached out to David regarding his “Questions,” he immediately invited me into a sphere of confidence and engaged me in dialogue. When I told him about the reading group we were planning, he gladly accepted the offer to come speak to us on the final day of our conversations. Around a table in my backyard and some cheap red wine, David gladly joined the discussion and fielded questions, even as things at one point got slightly heated. The group spawned many more reading groups, with people coming and going. Some continue to ponder the themes brought up then—the modern conception of death and medicine, the relations between Judaism and memory, professionalization, gender, institutionality and evil. Yet arguably, the framework of the discussions itself was the most influential result of the group, which we’ve since gone on to apply in more a formalized humanities project. It is likely that the shape of this model had much to do with the choice of text with which we began. I am grateful to David for providing the occasion as well as the support for our efforts to create para-academic spaces for intellectual practice, as well as for being an example, in the sense he ascribes to Illich in his biography, for how to remain intellectually curious, faithful, and rigorous.

——

——

John Winslow Verity

John Winslow Verity had a website called New Scare City: https://backpalm.blogspot.com/Most but not all that’s on there is about Ivan Illich.

From John Verity, May 15, 2013, to David: I imagine you're aware of the doc. film shot at CIDOC in the mid-1970s by a German guy named Gordian Troeller: "No Respect for Sacred Cows": German film with good English subtitles 1976, when Cidoc was closing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=epD932IBF_Yb

There’s a 1972 French TV interview with Illich. I thought I had landed a scoop when I recently found that video for sale in France (I paid!), from an archive, but evidently not. I mentioned it on my blog and then, Sajay very quickly produced the transcripts that you'd provided to him a week earlier and someone else (a Marty Kent, out here in Calif.) wrote to point out that the program has been posted publicly on the Vimeo site:

    https://vimeo.com/58170701

On Jul 11, 2013, at 1:27 PM, David Cayley wrote: Thanks, John...hoping I'm going to see you in Oakland at Sajay's conference at the end of the month.

Sat, Jul 13, 2013, John wrote: you bet. I live an hour and a bit northwest of Oakland, in Sonoma Cty., so will be there. looking forward to it. perhaps there will be some time to hang out before the actual evening talks.

Fri, Mar 14, 2014, from David to Jutta: John Verity posted this interesting interview with Lee on his website New Scare City:http://www.conversations.org/story.php?sid=5 It's long, but it brought it brought Lee very much alive in my mind.

——

——

Scott Flemming

Oct.21, 2026, from Scott: Hi David, I teach Industrial Engineering at Dalhousie. After reading Tools for Conviviality and the Rivers North of the Future I realize how your getting an email from an Industrial Engineer (sometimes called Systems Engineer) is perhaps hilarious.  I believe that the world is indeed over-industrialized and I am attempting to get my students to de-industrialize their imaginations partially through thinking about "Tools for Conviviality." 

I have an interesting background in that I have specialized in industrial engineering but I have also received an M.Div. From Knox College (U of T) and so the concept that "corruptio optimi pessima" makes a lot of sense to me. 

I wonder if you'd be open to be on my podcast ("The Useful Artist") where I am basically trying to learn about how it maybe possible for engineers to create convivial tools. I am banking episodes before I release the podcast but have the first one below  made with my friend and philosophy professor Neb Kujundzic (University of Prince Edward Island):https://youtu.be/WkkFF1DrNUA. Shorts pulled from the full podcast: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLz5Tl0GCbXhgm_lYYnLXSly8OtZ30695y. I have another one scheduled for recording next month with Ruby Justice Theolot, a professor from NYU in media studies (he grew up in Montreal and went to McGill).

Oct.25, 2026, from David: Thanks for your letter.  I'm happy to talk with you and have you record the conversation for your podcast.  Mornings are good for me - not next week - but beginning the week after - Nov. 3 and following days.  I'll be glad to discuss Illich, but you might want to know that I've just published a new book - https://sutherlandhousebooks.com/product/the-cbc/

Oct.28, 2026, from Scott: We have fall break at Dalhousie on the week of Nov 10th-14th - perhaps we could meet in a morning then if that would suit you.  I have been listening to podcasts and lectures and so on to sort of get some background on Illich and did hear about your new book. I do see a connection between conviviality and a CBC that takes dialogue seriously and would be happy to at the very least (if not more) than chat about the content of the new book while we are at it.  I would like to send you a brief set of bullet points on the sorts of questions I might ask you to sketch out a potential path, but, the day of I would rather follow where the conversation takes us.  

Feb 5, 2026, from Scott: David, as I prepare to release the podcast I am kicking myself I didn't have Esteva's name on the tip of the tongue at one point. Juan Lucena knew Carl Mitcham at Colorado School of Mines and Lucena quotes Gustavo Esteva in his "engineering and sustainable community development" which I mentioned in our conversation. The quote is below. I am kicking myself as I am almost through your 5 part CBC series on Illich 'part moon....' and realize of course Esteva knew Illich all along and perhaps why this quote below resonated with me years before I ever heard of Ivan.

Gustavo Esteva, a grassroots activist and intellectual in Oaxaca, Mexico, is particularly wary of this drive to help. When Americans or others offer “help,” he urges, “Don’t come [to my community] to help! Come to listen, to find out if our struggles are your struggles. Then and only then, we can sit and discuss how, if at all, we can work together” (personal communication).

Oct.10, 2026, from Scott: I have a conference paper here that I have been allowed to post on research gate: depending on how the link works for you I would be more than happy to have you share it! https://www.researchgate.net/publication/394260420_Ethical_and_Sustainable_Engineering_Design_A_Design_for_Conviviality_Approach