Interview: William Cavanaugh, After Atheism, Part Three
Letters:
Aug 28, 2018, from David: I learned yesterday from Sajay Samuel that you have commented on the book of Illich's early writings that the Penn State Press will be publishing in December. Thank you. Sajay, whom I've copied, intends to launch the book will a small gathering in State College at the very end of November (Nov. 30-Dec. 2), and we're both wondering if you'd be able to join us. Not a full-blown conference by any means...something smaller and more leisurely with lots of time for food, drink and fellowship, in the style of the man we're remembering. Sajay and I and another friend, Carl Mitcham, will speak, as will Wolfgang Palaver from Innsbruck who's in Princeton this fall (and someone, I suspect, you might know.) We'd love to have you there to share your thoughts as well. There is money for your travel and accomodation, and it's not that far from Chicago to State College. Any chance you could come?
Aug 29, 2018, from Bill: It's great to hear from you. Thanks very much for the invitation. I hate to say "no" again, but I'm at Notre Dame on a fellowship. One of the conditions of the fellowship is that we are in residence here for the duration. Given that this is my first sabbatical since 2001, and it's only a semester, I have turned down every invitation for the fall. Please accept my regrets. It sounds like a great program, and it would be great to meet you in person and see Wolfgang again. But for now I will have to decline.
Aug 30, 2018, from David: I understand, of course, but I'm sorry just the same. I hope there'll be another chance down the road. Meanwhile thanks for supporting The Powerless Church. I'll be in touch again when my book on Illich is done - I hope to have it in the hands of the Penn State Press by later in the fall.
——
Sep 12, 2019, from Bill: I'm writing to ask if you might entertain an invitation to come speak on Ivan Illich at DePaul in Chicago next April. I am now director of a research center on the Catholic Church in the global South, and our big annual conference next year is going to be on healthcare and the Church in the global South. We will have people from around the world talking about what works and what doesn't in Catholic healthcare, the theological foundations for thinking about these issues, North-South cooperation, the collision between Western and non-Western medicine, etc. I thought that you might be the ideal person to shake things up a bit and offer Illich's take on the practice of medicine, relating it, insofar as it's possible, to his Catholicism and his work in Latin America.
I'd like you to be one of the keynote speakers at the conference, which will take place over the weekend of April 17-19, 2020. We can cover all your expenses plus a modest $1500 honorarium. I'll send you a more formal invitation if you are open to it. But first I wanted to gauge your interest.
I'd love to finally meet you in person.
Sep 13, 2019, from David: Off the top of my head this sounds like something I would like to do. My book should be in press by then, and I had anticipated that, as of next year, I would have to start standing up for it, so your invitation exactly fits. Plus it would be a chance to meet you - at last. So, tentatively, yes...
A veil of discretion is supposed to lie over the identity of the readers of my Illich MS, but it was not difficult to descry your features in what came to me as the comments of "reader two." Thank you for your generous endorsement, as well as for your more critical comments. The reader reports - yours along with that of the equally enthusiastic, and helpfully critical "reader one" (Wolfgang Palaver) - have given the Penn State Press the confidence to proceed and to seek a co-publication arrangement with the McGll/Queens Press here in Canada. They have also given me a set of pointed questions with which to undertake a final - I hope - revision which I expect to complete within the month.
Sep 13, 2019, from Bill: That's great news, David! My assistant will send you a formal letter of invitation.
Now that I have been outed as "reader two," let me tell you how excited I was to read your book and how happy that it will soon be available to the public. It's terrific, and I learned so much from it.
— —
September 16, 2019, from Karen Kraft: Dear Mr. Cayley:
In April of 2020, the Center for World Catholicism & Intercultural Theology (CWCIT) of DePaul University in Chicago will host its 12th annual World Catholicism Week conference. Titled “Rise Up and Walk: Catholicism and Health Across the Globe,” the conference will take place here at DePaul over the weekend of April 17-19, 2020 (Friday afternoon through Sunday evening). I would like to invite you to join us as one of our two keynote speakers, giving a 45-minute presentation on the conference theme. I know you receive many invitations, but I am hoping that the global focus of the conference and DePaul’s Vincentian tradition will be added incentives for you to accept.
The CWCIT (http://cwcit.depaul.edu) is a research center at DePaul that focuses on the global dimensions of Catholicism, particularly in the global South—Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Each year, World Catholicism Week gathers scholars and practitioners from around the world to reflect on a theme. The theme for 2020 is Catholicism and health care around the world. Topics may include Catholic health care services, biblical and theological narratives of health and healing, Catholicism and the relationship between Western and non-Western medicine, trauma and invisible wounds, Catholic health care ethics, caring for those wounded by the Church, and others. As keynote speaker, you would be free to draw on your extensive expertise in Catholic health care to address the topic from any angle you would see fit. Some connection with health care issues in the global South would be especially appreciated.
Our other invited speakers include the following: Sr. Carol Keehan, DC–Outgoing President/CEO, Catholic Health Association (Washington, DC); David Toole—Associate Professor of the Practice of Theology, Ethics, and Global Health, Duke Global Health Institute (Durham, NC, USA); Sr. Dr. Maria Vasantha—Medical Superintendent, Leonard Hospital (Batlagundu, Tamil Nadu, India); Alexandre Martins—Assistant Professor of Theology, Marquette University (Milwaukee, WI, USA); Fr. Stan Chu Ilo—Associate Professor of Theology & CWCIT Research Professor, DePaul University (Chicago); Fr. Paulino Twesigye Mondo, MCCI—Immediate Past Director, Reach Out Mbuya HIV Initiative (Kampala); Kochurani Abraham—Regional Coordinator, Indian Christian Women’s Movement for Kerala; Vice President, Indian Theological Association (Bengaluru, Kamataka, India); Fr. Bernhard Udelhoven, SMA—Founder, “Fingers of Thomas” support group, and staff member of FENZA—Faith & Encounter Centre Zambia (Lusaka); Sr. Joan Mumaw, IHM—President & Chief Administrative Officer, Friends in Soliarity (Silver Spring, MD, USA); David Gaus, MD—Founder & CEO, Andean Health & Development (Rural Ecuador); Sam Orach—Executive Secretary, Uganda Catholic Medical Bureau; Member, Health Policy Advisory; Committee, Uganda Ministry of Health (Kampala, Uganda).
In general, the time allotted for keynote presentations is 45 minutes, plus an additional 20-30 for audience Q&A.
——
Jan 4, 2021, from Karen: Dear friends, Hello from DePaul during these first few days of 2021! I hope that all of you are keeping well and have had a peaceful Christmas.
I’m writing with some very important requests and updates for our “Rise Up and Walk” conference on Zoom this April. As you know, there is always the possibility of unforeseen technical difficulties during an online event, and we want to be as prepared as possible. To that end, we would like to ask each of you to please record a video of yourself giving your conference presentation, well in advance.
Could we ask you to send us your video file—along with the text of your final presentation—by Friday, March 19?
We understand that, for some of you, this might be an incredibly ambitious request, but we hope that we are asking far enough in advance that you have time to prepare. These videos will serve as “insurance,” in case something goes wrong with your internet connection on the day of your conference presentation. If that happens, and you aren’t able to get online, we will be able to show your video and not lose the contribution and insight you bring to this important conference.
Jan 4, 2021, from David: Thanks for your recent letter. There have been some changes in my life, since I agreed […] that I would make my address to the conference as planned, but not otherwise participate. Towards the end of November, I began to develop serious angina, and an angiogram has since revealed fairly extensive blockages in my coronary arteries. The upshot is that I will have open heart surgery and multiple bypasses on Jan. 15th. How this will go is uncertain. With a good recovery I should be able to make your March 19th deadline, but I wanted to let you both know that that might be in doubt if there are any complications. I will write again in February when I know my situation better. I hope this is acceptable. If you want to cancel me and substitute someone you can count on with more confidence, I will understand. If not, I'll write when I can.
Jan.8, 2021, from Karen: Thank you for writing […] and please forgive this delayed reply…I am so sorry to learn of the angina that has developed since we were last in touch and the resulting need for you to undergo open-heart surgery next week. Please rest assured of our prayers…that both the surgery and the recovery are successful and sans complications. Regarding the conference, we all agree that we would hate to lose your contribution as a keynoter. We’re glad to wait to hear from you in February, when you have a little recovery time under your belt and can better assess how you are doing. […] Count on our prayers for next Friday, David…and please take good care in the coming weeks. God bless….
Jan 9, 2021, from Bill: I just wanted to add my concern to that of Karen. I'm sorry to hear of your medical issues, and I will be praying that all goes well for you. Please let us know, when you can, how the surgery went, and let us know if there is anything you need from us.
Jan 11, 2021, from David: Thanks for your letters. Since I wrote, I have decided to postpone the surgery because of the uncertain effect of rising COVID numbers on the hospital (and me as its patient), and because current restrictions on visitors would make me a virtual captive, cut off from all my loved ones, should something go wrong. Happily I feel quite well and able to sustain the delay. The surgery is not yet rescheduled, but 'll certainly be able to deliver my recorded lecture before March 19th. So count on that, and I'll be in touch later on.
Jan 11, 2021, from Bill: Thanks, David. I'm glad to hear that you're feeling well and can wait until the pandemic gets a little more under control. We're very much looking forward to your talk. I can imagine that you might have a thing or two to say about the pandemic.
——
Jan 26, 2026, from David: Greetings from snowbound Toronto - where a couple of feet of snow fell on the city yesterday.
Quite a few years ago I invited you to an Illich gathering - I think it was in Oakland when Jerry Brown was the mayor there - and you said you would have liked to come even though you couldn't. Here I am trying again. My friend Sajay Samuel, a professor at Penn State, is inviting contributions to a volume called The Challenges of Ivan Illich - a sequel to a book of that name which appeared just before Ivan died. I've attached his call for papers. He intends to host a gathering in State College, PA in the first week of August this coming summer where some of those contributions will be discussed. I wonder if there's any chance you could come.
I've also attached an essay I've just provisionally completed, which tries to read C.G. Jung with and against Illich, and for which I'm not seeking interlocutors, since it's written, pretty much, from the frontier of my understanding. It's long, and I have no wish to impose it on you, but I don't want to completely hide my light under a bushel either, so I leave it to you to decide if it's of interest.
I've just begun reading your Uses of Idolatry. I send you my best wishes.
2 Attachments • (Jung essay and Challenges 2 conference outline)
Jan 27, 2026, from Bill: It's great to hear from you. I still regret not being able to attend that gathering in Oakland. Unfortunately, I can't be at the State College gathering either. I'll be doing a series of talks in Switzerland the first week of August.
I'm really sorry about this. I plan to finally do a serious dive into Illich for my next book, which is probably ten years from appearing in print. In the meantime, I will read your essay on Illich and Jung with rapt attention.
Jan 28, 2026, from David: Thanks for yours. I'm sorry to hear about this summer, and Sajay's book, but delighted that Illich is on your horizon - however far it may stretch.
If you do read the essay I sent you, I hope you will read it charitably as the work of a theological ingénue who is trying to get certain questions clearer in his mind rather than as some sort of statement of position - I'm a long way from that.